ipl-logo

The Giver Movie And Book Comparison Essay

692 Words3 Pages

The book The Giver depicts a utopian like society where everyone is equal. As well as, describing the lives of those who live there and the faults the community has. Years later The Giver was recreated into a movie adaptation. The book The Giver and the movie, however, contain outrageous differences in plot affecting the overall view the reader/audience have on the story. Including, but not limited too, Fiona’s feelings for Jonas and Jonas’ plan to leave the community. The movie’s interpretation of the book tarnishes key points in the book. Also, changing the message the book is trying to portray, just for the sake of entertainment purposes.

The relationship between Fiona and Jonas is described mainly as a close friendship. Talking …show more content…

Jonas, having developed emotions is completely shocked and disturbed that his father could do something so evil. Everything he thought was real and pure changes. He wants everyone in his community to know what their actions mean and how it’s not just. Jonas conveys his thoughts to the Giver and they devises a plan to leave the community. Jonas would take his bike and leave with Gabriel during a community assemble and the Giver would cover for him. The movie depicts a completely different event, one that is much more impulsive. Jonas does watch the same video of his father, but doesn’t decide to leave just then. He goes home to the news of Gabriel’s soon release. Filled with rage he storms out of his family unit and bikes to the Nurturer Center to retrieve Gabe. Running into many obstacles of the way. The movie ending is dramatically different from the books, not including the true nature of the Givers actions. In the book you discover that it was the Giver’s plan to have Jonas be another failure and for him to leave the community. This way he would be released to elsewhere and could be with Rosemary forever in eternity. Therefore, having Jonas’ escape to elsewhere be portrayed as his own plan, doesn’t allow the audience to realize the true intentions of the author when describing their

Show More
Related

The Giver: Similarities And Differences

180 Words | 1 Pages

During the Ceremony of 12 Jonas was called last in both the book and movie. A final thing they have in common is that release meant the same thing, being killed. Though there were some similarities there were also some differences. One major difference is in the book Gabriel and Jonas both have “pale eyes” but in the movie,they have the same birthmark.

Read More

The Giver Quote Analysis

1518 Words | 7 Pages

(STEWE-1) Jonas now knowing the truth has broken him into a thousand pieces. This is a big moment because this is when the giver and Jonas begin to plan his escape. Jonas is desperate to be with the giver because it is his only real relationship “I 'll do it. I think I can do it.

Read More

Similarities And Differences Between The Giver Movie And Movie

852 Words | 4 Pages

Some of the major differences, such as the changes in Jonas, Fiona, and Asher’s characters in the movie as well as Jonas’s escape, really separate the movie from the book. However, that is not to say that there are not plenty of similarities. The descriptions and portrayals of Jonas’s feelings about the Community, The Giver, and the structure of the Community are very similar between the two stories. While the similarities greatly outnumber the differences, some of the differences are very major and can change the story a

Read More

The Giver Movie Vs Book Analysis

720 Words | 3 Pages

The cliffhanger ending is more powerful because we are left to wonder Jonas and Gabriel’s fate and we don’t have anything decided for us. In chapter 23 Lowry writes, “For the first time he heard something that he knew to be music. He heard people signing”(179). Since Jonas had never heard music before it makes us wonder how he knows what it is. He could be dead and be hearing music or he could be having a memory from the Giver but we don’t really know.

Read More

The Giver Conflicts

503 Words | 3 Pages

Is that he is brave to take back what was taken from him and everybody in the community. One scene from the book is when Jonas finds a map of the stone towers that sealed away the things that were taken from him by the chief elder and so the only way to get them back is if he gets out of the giant land in the sky the place where he and the community live and goes back down to earth and cross the stone towers field but if he does that he can never go back to the community, but he gives back what was stolen from him and everyone in the community by the chief elder. And Jonas became a hero in their community. The novel ends by Jonas giving back what was stolen from him and everyone by

Read More

Jonas Hardships In The Giver

535 Words | 3 Pages

Jonas and the Giver had discussed their plan and Jonas would have to leave at a certain point at night so he would not be caught. If he was caught, he would be released along with Gabe. Luckily Jonas did escape the community with Gabe and found their destination, elsewhere. This was hard because if he made one mistake, it could mean life or

Read More

The Giver Quotes

939 Words | 4 Pages

He is revolted that so many people he knows are killers.(SIP-B) Jonas rejects his society and abandons the Giver’s plan because society is trying to take away the only person he loved.(STEWE-1) When Gabe could not sleep soundly without Jonas the Nurtures decided to release him even his father “I voted for Gabriels release” (Lowry 165). Jonas’s own father is trying to take away the only person that he still has a relationship with.(STEWE-2) When Jonas hears that Gabe is going to be released he wants to save him.

Read More

The Giver Movie And Book Comparison

579 Words | 3 Pages

In the book, the author stated that “Jonas did not want to go back to receive memories, but he still went there”. In the movie however, he tries to completely abandon his training and go back to having an ignorant life. The producer did this to create drama and suspense for the

Read More

Jonas: Changing The Community In The Giver

517 Words | 3 Pages

Jonas plans to change the community by releasing memories to the community. When Jonas gets to elsewhere when he escapes the community all his memories will leave him and go to the citizens of his community. The people will be panicked. The Giver will stay in the community to calm the people and help them through it.

Read More

The Giver Compare And Contrast Essay

718 Words | 3 Pages

Based on my criteria, I come to the conclusion that the movie version of The Giver is superior to the book in these two ways. The main reason I believe the movie is better than the book is because it made me feel more in the perspective of Jonas, instead of a bystander. Without freedom, choice ,color , or individuality, life just would be meaningless and

Read More

Differences Between The Giver Book And Movie

370 Words | 2 Pages

In the book, Jonas does not want to quit being the receiver, in the movie he does. Jonas wants to quit being the receiver because he does not like keeping secrets. In order to be the receiver, you have to keep secrets about your training. But Jonas wants to share everything. He talks to Fiona and she says that he can't quit.

Read More

Jonas's Decisions In 'The Giver'

1605 Words | 7 Pages

My father killed it! Jonas said to himself, stunned at what he was realizing. ”(Lowry 150). He had just watched his father kill an infant without any care or he didn't feel anything. This is the major point that pushes Jonas over the edge and he starts to make a plan of escape with the Giver.(STEWE-2)Jonas’s father

Read More

Examples Of Persuasive Essay On The Giver

478 Words | 2 Pages

Therefore, Jonas and Gabriel circled back around to their community and survived. At the end of the book “The Giver” Jonas and Gabe circled around back to his community and Jonas started to gather his memories again. When Jonas and Gabe reached the top of the hill and Jonas saw a sled and slid down, it was just like his memory the giver gave him. In the book when Rosemary asked for release her memories she received went to the people so when Jonas left, his memories went to the people and when he circled around and started to gather them again.

Read More

Choices In The Giver

440 Words | 2 Pages

In Lois Lowry's novel the giver, the main theme is that some people have to make choices. Jonas shows the importance of choices in this book when he leaves to help Gabe. In the following scene, Jonas left the society. “That night Jonas was forced to flee. He left the dwelling shortly after the sky became dark and the community still (pg.163).”

Read More

The Giver Compare And Contrast Essay

420 Words | 2 Pages

The Giver Compare and Contrast By: Nick R “I feel sorry for anyone who is in a place where he feels strange and stupid.” (Lowe) This is true because no place is perfect and that is why The Giver is a dystopian novel and not like our world. Although The Giver our modern-day society are different, they have many similarities, such as Climate/Weather, Birthdays, jobs, and Families, color.

Read More

More about The Giver Movie And Book Comparison Essay

Related Topics

Open Document