ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of Animal Experimentation And Judaism

1757 Words8 Pages

Animal Experimentation Science has rapidly evolved in recent years. Medically we are more advanced than we have ever been before and our level of technological expansion is beyond anything that we could have comprehended. However even with all of this advancement we still resort to animal experimentation. There are both pros and cons to this lack of advancement. Animal experimentation is considered to be taboo for many people yet on the flip side it’s considered a necessity to others. Religion is also a very big factor in determining people’s opinion for this. Christianity for example can be taken both ways. For those supporting animal experimentation they could claim that since animals have no souls they cannot reason. Therefore they can be experimented on without any qualms because they have no soul to injure or torment. Not only this but they can claim that God created animals for man to use …show more content…

Judaism believes that Tzar Baalei Chayim, which means to avoid causing pain to any living creature, must be maintained at all time. Judaism teaches that any of God’s creations must be treated with compassion. If you are mistreating an animal for no reason other than your own desire it is seen as being against the Tzar Baalei Chayim which is a huge problem for the religion seeing as the followers take it to heart. However that is not to say that certain aspects of animal experimentation are not accepted. The only reason that it is acceptable to harm, kill, or experiment on animals is if it fulfills an essential human need. If experimenting on this animal will help cure a disease then it is acceptable. However there is a limitation to that. If the animal is in unnecessary pain and suffering than there is no excuse and it is wrong in the eyes of this religion. The animal cannot be in any pain that is deemed unnecessary and cannot be in any discomfort that is not required to help the essential human

Show More
Related
1277 Words | 6 Pages

In a laboratory, all of the animals are crammed into small cages with no food or water, stretching room or fresh air to breath. Another regulatory requirement is that the United States Department of Agriculture requires institutions to report the number of animals used in research and the number of animals that experience pain or distress. In my opinion, this is far worse than any kind of animal abuse or torture; this is pure evil. Animal experimentation is inhumane because all of the animals are commonly subjected to force-feeding, forced inhalation, food and water deprivation, prolonged periods of physical restraint and numerous amounts of suffering that no animal should ever have to go through during its life. Animals are here to love and protect us, whether they are domestic or not.

Read More
1132 Words | 5 Pages

It is wrong to kill animals for scientific purposes because killing of any kind is unethical and animals should be left in their rightful habitat. Although large discoveries may be made from observing killed animals, scientists should make greater efforts to keep their subjects alive and thriving. Captivating animals for studies or entertainment should be seen as animal abuse, and animal abuse should not be condoned under any

Read More
627 Words | 3 Pages

I think that scientist and psychologist shouldn’t be able to do unnecessary experiments on animals. The first reason that I think they shouldn’t is because most of the time these animals don’t survive these procedures. It isn’t right to instantly end an animal’s life, as well as its wrong to end a human’s life. On top of these innocent killings us human’s show little to no remorse. Most people believe that animals don’t suffer or feel pain but according to Victoria Braithwaite even fish feel pain.

Read More
1188 Words | 5 Pages

Americans are choosing to mute their opinions on this heated topic “Although 25% of Americans say they believe animals deserve the "exact same rights" as people to be free from harm and exploitation, many of these same people oppose proposals to limit the harm and exploitation of animals.” (Moore, 2003) It is inhumane to physically and mentally hurt an animal; they are receptive to the same amount of pain and discomfort as humans. Therefore why are they a fair component for research and testing? Humans feel that since we are the rulers of creation, that all power is in our hands to diminish animal’s lives.

Read More
1066 Words | 5 Pages

Animal experimentation is unacceptable because it is unethical. The article “Animal Experimentation” it states, “many people object to the use of animals in scientific studies because the animals are denied their freedom and often suffer serious injury and discomfort.” People disagree with animal experimentation because the animals do not have the freedom to choose. Animals cannot speak for themselves to tell whether or not they want to get tested on, because of this then the animals that are tested on suffer a lot of discomfort and injuries. Another reason why animal experimentation is unethical because it is unreliable.

Read More
1016 Words | 5 Pages

People have animals, especially dogs and cats, as pets. They take care of animals and spend their lives together. However, sacrificing animals is necessary for human life to survive. Moreover, using animal experimentation is common because this can improve our health. Henry E. Heffner and Carl Cohen who are proponents of animal experimentation point out that it is necessary because it can protect human health.

Read More
1079 Words | 5 Pages

6. The colossal differences between animals and humans make them poor model to be experimented. 7. Animals don’t have neither the rights nor the ability to oppose being experimented. Thus, it’s not wrong to experiment on them.

Read More
574 Words | 3 Pages

Animals are subjected to excruciating experiments daily. Countries such as Israel and India have stopped animal testing as well as Britain. “…countless animals are experimented on and then killed…” (Murnaghan 1). Animals are subjected to confined rooms all of their lives, used in painful experiments and then disposed of as if they are an inanimate object.

Read More
1111 Words | 5 Pages

Although the experimentation of animals has furthered medical knowledge, it should not be allowed because it is brutal and animals are unable to give their approval. In order to do a study on humans it must be authorized by them, where animals are unable to give consent, which strikes questions in the world of science on whether this is morally acceptable. Although animal experimentation can result in saving the lives of millions, many find it to be cruel and unjust. Seeing as animals are unable to speak for themselves, they are still able to express their emotions through their behavior.

Read More
1369 Words | 6 Pages

Animals should not be experimented on for research purposes because it's cruel to the animals, it's ineffective, and it is outdated. Animal experimentation can force feed animals, keep animals from drinking and eating, hurt the animals to see how they would heal, and keep them away

Read More
795 Words | 4 Pages

Expert in psychology Helene Guldberg said, "Human beings, unlike other animals, are able to reflect on and make judgements about our own and others' actions, and as a result we are able to make considered moral choices" (Guldberg, Helene: 2011). Animals are similar to us in DNA and sensory features, however they do not have the capability of think reflect or think morally. It is acceptable to experiment on animals because it saves our lives. People think argue that animal experimentation is cruel but let animal experimentation not be confused with animal torture. Those who enjoy inflicting pain or unnecessary test on animal for no purpose, now that is animal cruelty.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

The reason why people would be against animal experiments is firstly the pain and harm that is inflicted on them as animals are not given pain killers as scientist

Read More
864 Words | 4 Pages

The harm animals undergo includes being infected with diseases they would not otherwise be susceptible to, electrocution, and having their spines crushed. This treatment that people are often unaware of is immoral, cruel, and unethical.

Read More
1411 Words | 6 Pages

review of relevant ethical issues, including the choice of ethical theory A significant aspect to consider when discussing the issue of animal experimentation focuses on people’s views of animals. Mostly everyone would agree that animals are entitled to respect, which is why it is unethical to mistreat pets or aimlessly hurts animals. The question is, how much respect are they owed and what rights, if any, do they have? How much should they be allowed to suffer in research?

Read More
1814 Words | 8 Pages

There is no one solution to the use of animal experimentation, because the issue is complex. Animal experimentation provides humans with valuable, life-saving medical knowledge in some cases, but it can also be an outlet for animal cruelty. So, the best way to deal with this issue is to pass legislation that is just as complex as the issue itself. A law in New Zealand and Sweden is good example of this. Both these countries passed a law that requires research institutions to obtain a permit and prove that their research would be beneficial to chimpanzees if they wished to experiment on them.

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of Animal Experimentation And Judaism

Related Topics

Open Document