ipl-logo

Tony Nicklinson Assisted Suicide Essay

1867 Words8 Pages

On the 20th of August 2012, Tony Nicklinson died just six days after he lost his case. Nicklinson wanted to be allowed to end his life with the help of a doctor after being paralysed from the neck down following a stroke. This is an example of how assisted suicide is regularly featured in the public eye and how there is mounting pressure from the public for the law on assisted suicide to be developed and further clarified. The case of Nicklinson and others in 2014, like many similar cases, has illustrated the UK’s desperate need for the reformation of the law on assisted suicide.
In this essay I will argue that the public are mislead by the media to believe that English judges impose artificial and undesirable limits on their own power to change the law. I will explain how the reformation of this law is primarily down to Parliament as they, as a democratically elected body, can ensure that the whole nation’s view on this sensitive topic is reflected in new legislation.

The Current Law on Assisted Suicide
The Suicide Act of 1961 decriminalised suicide, but assisted suicide remains a serious crime where ‘a person who aids, abets, counsels or procures …show more content…

This was rejected. The Divisional Court stated the reasons for this. Firstly, it would diminish the DPP’s flexibility if they were to make the code more specific. Also, it would be impractical for the DPP to create guidelines that could cover all people who commit assisted suicide not for a loved one like a carer or a doctor. Thirdly, it would require the DPP to cross a constitutional line by creating a scheme that could decide the probability that an individual would or would not be prosecuted. Because of these reasons the issue of assisted suicide cannot be resolved by further attempts to get clarification of the DPP’s

Show More
Related

Hill Bosscher Case Summary

1039 Words | 5 Pages

Freedman worries about the conceptual slippery slope associated with physician assisted suicide. Ultimately, he believes that allowing physician assisted suicide will lead to the approval of euthanasia (154). In many situations it is unclear how to deal with requested physician suicide, especially in cases where the patient has a physical disability. In such cases, it is difficult or impossible for a patient to self-administer the lethal dose of medication to end his or her own life. It therefore rules out physician assisted suicide, but denying the patient the right to end his or her own life as they choose is against the charter of rights and undermines his or her autonomy (155).

Read More

Sue Rodriguez Essay

542 Words | 3 Pages

It has been 21 years and physician-assisted suicide is still one of the biggest legal issues today and in the Supreme Court. “When Sue Rodriguez took her case to court, she changed the very nature of the decision-making process that might affect how she would live out her final days and how she would die. She tried to change the law of the land” (Bereza). This impacted today’s society and law; in fact the federal government will appear in front of the BC Court of Appeal later this month for discussion of the band on assisted-suicide. The crucial debate on this controversial topic continues to

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

1121 Words | 5 Pages

Described and compared cases reported in the first five years of legislation. Those whom are suffering should get their wishes on assisted suicide. Many people are against Physician Assisted Suicide. Many religions prohibits taking one's own life. They believe that it is against God's will.

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Case Study

1971 Words | 8 Pages

However the act did not legalise physician assisted suicide and so that practice still remained illegal. This seems ridiculous to me as why should physician assisted suicide not be allowed if normal suicide is allowed, both involve someone who wants to end their life, so it shouldn’t matter how they choose to do it. Many people may be scared to take their own life and would prefer a doctor to do it for them. This is why physician assisted suicide should be

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Physician Assisted Suicide

686 Words | 3 Pages

there shouldn't be an option of assisted suicide when there is help waiting for

Read More

Dying With Dignity (DWD)

903 Words | 4 Pages

To provide more light on to the issues with the probation of assisted suicide, an intervenor called Dying with Dignity (DWD) takes the stance with the trial judge and believes in the right to have assisted deaths legalized within Canada. They wish to have it apart of the health care system, but emphasizes, just like Smith, that there must be safeguards that are meticulously enforced and reviewed. They have five submissions that expresses their thoughts and position within the decisions and thoughts behind the SCC Carter case: 1) they believe that the right to life also includes the right to die with dignity. Life should be interpreted broadly and that should also include how it ends. DWD argue that by placing a ban on assisted suicide determines

Read More

Physician Assisted Suicide Argumentative Essay

1290 Words | 6 Pages

Physician assisted suicide is one of the most complex and critical health care policy issues that doctors and nurses must face and either advocate for or against. What makes it difficult is determining whether or not the patient’s condition is poor enough to be considered eligible for this type of treatment. In 1990, Dr. Jack Kevorkian started a movement of taking this practice forward himself and helping multiple people do what they wanted with their life. Physician assisted suicide (PAS) can be a respectful way for people to be let free of their misery if done at the request of the patient. PAS can be seen as a negative act that doctors and nurses have the power to over use.

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

702 Words | 3 Pages

Meghan Wong Period 5 2/12/15 Proposal for Euthanasia and Physician-Assisted Suicide (PAS) 1. The controversial issue I have chosen is about the current ban of euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide. Euthanasia, sometimes referred as “mercy killing,” is the medical term of a physician administering any lethal agent to end a patients’ life. The two main types of euthanasia are active and passive; active euthanasia is defined as the physician directly administering the agent to the patient, while passive euthanasia is when the physician purposely withholds whatever life support the patient is on. Physician-assisted suicide, on the other hand, is similarly related to active euthanasia; the physician provides the patient with euthanasia though medicinal means, and allows the patient to be in-control of his death.

Read More

Essay On Euthanasia In Canada

874 Words | 4 Pages

It is believed that once practicing physician-assisted suicides becomes an acceptable concept in society, the next steps will easily be taken toward unethical actions such as involuntary euthanasia. Edmund D. Pellegrino, MD, Professor Emeritus of Medicine and Medical Ethics at Georgetown University claims that our healthcare system is too obsessed with costs and principles of utility. He defies the belief that the slippery slope effect is no more than a prediction, by reminding the outlooks and inclinations of our society. Furthermore, he believes there comes a day that incompetent patients and those in coma won’t be asked for their permission to use euthanasia. The Netherlands is another example of such misuse.

Read More

Euthanasia In Australia Essay

703 Words | 3 Pages

Fear that assisted suicide may be used to end people’s lives when a miracle recovery is right around the corner, or cut someone’s life short when they aren’t ready to die. But legalising euthanasia doesn’t mean it becomes a free for all. Part of the suggested law involves a framework that doctors MUST follow to regulate euthanasia. This means that in order for someone to be given ‘euthanasia’, two seperate doctors must agree that the illness is in fact incurable, and the patient must be mentally stable enough to give honest and genuine consent. With such laws in place, we can ensure the safety and protection of patients without forcing them to miserable suffer while they await their natural

Read More

Autonomy Vs. Voluntary Euthanasia

1399 Words | 6 Pages

The main purpose of this chapter is to establish the definitions that surround the issue of euthanasia and to establish the main dilemma experienced by government. This is the dilemma between upholding the value of individual autonomy and protecting vulnerable citizens. The debate on the issue of Euthanasia, and more specifically assisted dying is highly contested and therefore this project sets out a table of definitions for the purpose of clarity. Although these definitions vary depending on source and are regularly criticised for either being too narrow or too wide, I will base my project on the definitions found below. Voluntary Euthanasia

Read More

Legalization Of Euthanasia In The Independent By Jerome Taylor

516 Words | 3 Pages

I am writing to you today to inform you of my views on the legalization of euthanasia. I inform you that I have read the article in The Independent, written by Jerome Taylor, and will also refer to the subject of it, Tony Nicklinson. I believe that if euthanasia was legalised, it should only be a controlled procedure, with strict guidelines such as the patient proving that they have sufficient mental capacity to make their own choices, and to be able to give a reason why they should be euthanized, and how they should be euthanized. Others in favour of my argument believe that our society should allow those who wish to die, yet do not have the capacity to kill themselves, should be allowed to die with dignity and without having to experience pain. I fully agree with this statement because in the article written by The Independent, a victim of locked-in syndrome known as Tony Nicklinson wishes for the doctors to euthanize him, as he physically cannot kill himself, which directly correlates to the point made above, as he wished to be euthanized by the doctors without them having to be prosecuted.

Read More

Essay On Physician Assisted Suicide

965 Words | 4 Pages

It is argued that assisted suicide violates the deontological principle because it contradicts one's moral values and the sanctity of life (citation). The person actively assisting breaks the moral law due to their intentions to end a sacred life. According to John Keown, author of Euthanasia, Ethics and Public Policy: An Argument Against Legalisation, the main argument against assisted suicide is that it would be open to abuse and could lead to a ‘slippery slope’ effect, where increasing numbers of people would be coerced into choosing assisted suicide. He argues that it would be difficult to ensure that vulnerable people are not put under pressure to end their lives and that it would be hard to ensure that it is genuinely voluntary. Furthermore, assisted suicide would undermine the patient-doctor relationship, which is based on trust and the belief that the doctor will always act in the patient’s best interests.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Assisted Suicide

1273 Words | 6 Pages

(CBC News) With everyone’s opinion and everyone’s actions, the thought of assisted suicide will never resolve its controversial opinions in the years to

Read More

Hart Positivism

1093 Words | 5 Pages

In law people who carry out euthanasia are treated as committing murder or manslaughter. The Suicide Act 1961 makes a specific offence of criminal liability for aiding another’s suicide whereas suicide itself is legal. The case of R (Pretty) v DPP caused a stir in the euthanasia debate. Diane Pretty suffers due to a terminal illness and therefore requested to die at a time of her choosing to put an end to her pain. Pretty’s claim was unsuccessful due to the domestic realisation of the vast moral considerations at stake, and they therefore looked to the democratic will of parliament that can be found in legal text.

Read More

More about Tony Nicklinson Assisted Suicide Essay

Related Topics

Open Document