ipl-logo

What Extent Is The Nurse Responsible For The Deaths Of Romeo And Juliet Essay

903 Words4 Pages

Who is ultimately responsible for Romeo and Juliet’s deaths? When we say we can help, what do we mean when we talk about ‘helping’ ? In definition about help is “make it easier or possible for someone to do something by offering one's services or resources”. When it comes to this topic, some might argue that Nurse just wanted to help, but I believe that Nurse is ultimately responsible for Romeo and Juliet’s deaths because she secretly holds the relationship between Romeo and Juliet but then give up and has an attitude that shows she doesn’t care about anything. To begin, Nurse should be responsible for Romeo and Juliet's death because she secretly holds the relationship between Romeo and Juliet, but then give up helping Juliet after problems …show more content…

She said, "To comfort you. I wot well where he is. Hark ye, your Romeo will be here at night. I'll to him; he is hid at Laurence' cell” (3.5 222-223). After Romeo is in trouble, and the relationship between Romeo and Juliet has become a problem, Nurse should find a solution by telling everything to their parents, not keep secretly holding the relationship between them. She is not their parents. Any steps or decisions that she makes may cause problems, and if these problems are out of control, she will be the person that is responsible for it. Therefore, I think Nurse should be reasonable about Romeo and Juliet's death because she agrees and keeps holding the secret relationship between Romeo and Juliet. After Romeo had been punished, and Juliet’s parents want Juliet to marry Paris, Nurse went to Juliet's room and …show more content…

When Juliet wants to listen to what Remeo tells Nurse, she says, “Sweet, sweet, sweet Nurse tell me, what did my love Romeo say?” (2.5 53). Although some people will argue that Nurse just wants to help so that they can be happy ever after, In fact, no one will sacrifice their time and help others doing things that are not right for no reason, there must be something that he or she wants. Since Nurse wants to be the only window between Romeo and Juliet, so they will definitely rely on Nuse. As a result, Nurse can create an unbreakable relationship with Romeo and Juliet. But because Nurse is just an employee, she should only do her job well, not thinking about becoming an important window or creating a relationship with her boss'

Show More
Related

Compassion In Romeo And Juliet And The Book Thief

1147 Words | 5 Pages

After the Nurse speaks with Romeo she hurries back to the Capulet house to inform Juliet of her lover’s idea and tells her, “Hie you to church. I must go another way/To fetch a ladder, by which you love/Must climb a bird’s nest soon when it is dark” (II.v.77-79). The Nurse demonstrates her devotion to Juliet as she expresses her desire to find “another way” (II.v.77) to help the young lovers spend their wedding night together and by doing so risks losing her job. She understands the true passion Romeo and Juliet have for each other and does everything she can to make them happy even if that means upsetting their families. This teaches the reader that helping those you love is more important than doing something that does not align with your own morals, like separating two star-crossed lovers because of a centuries-old family

Read More

Romeo And Juliet Nurse Quotes

385 Words | 2 Pages

The nurse is the best character in Romeo and Juliet. She cares the most about Romeo and Juliet. The nurse is the only character that unselfishly cares about Juliet. Romeo cares about her for her physical appearance, her mom doesn’t really know her very well, her dad isn’t a huge part of her life either, and without the nurse, Juliet would be pretty much alone in the world. She also cares about Juliet’s love of Romeo, however, which makes her care about him.

Read More

Romeo And Juliet The Nurse Essay

478 Words | 2 Pages

Her naivety blinds her to the potential dangers of the clandestine marriage between Romeo and Juliet, leading to a lack of caution in their interactions. Rather than exercising prudence and urging restraint, the Nurse enables their forbidden love affair by facilitating their secret meetings, thereby disregarding the implications of their actions. Her negligence in considering the potential repercussions of their relationship directly contributes to the mounting tensions and escalating violence that ultimately leads to their untimely deaths. Despite her position of trust and loyalty to Juliet, the Nurse's allegiance proves questionable when confronted with conflicting loyalties. In Act III, when Juliet's world collapses following Romeo's banishment, the Nurse advises her to abandon Romeo and marry Paris, betraying the deep bond she once shared with Juliet.

Read More

The Nurse's Predicament In Romeo And Juliet

853 Words | 4 Pages

It would have been impossible for Juliet to even communicate with Romeo if it weren’t for the nurse. The nurse blindly followed Juliet's orders without thinking of the results her words and actions could cause. Juliet looks up to the nurse who has taken care of her for years. When the nurse provides Juliet with no initial guidance Juliet is forced into making the decision of staying loyal  to her husband or staying with her

Read More

Who Was Responsible For The Deaths Of Romeo And Juliet Essay

587 Words | 3 Pages

As it states on page 166 “ I think it best you marry County Paris”. This proves that with the banishment of Romeo, Juliet's lover she would never want to remarry which foreshadows the death of Juliet. In conclusion, the nurse is responsible for the death of Romeo and Juliet by Keeping Secrets, and telling Juliet to Marry Paris.

Read More

Who's To Blame For The Deaths Of Romeo And Juliet

808 Words | 4 Pages

The Nurse could be responsible for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet, but the one who is most to blame is the Friar. The Friar is mostly to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because he married Romeo and Juliet, left Juliet alone in the tomb, and made the plan for Romeo to come back to Verona and bring Juliet to Mantua with him. To start, Friar is mostly to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet because he married Romeo to Juliet. For example, “Come, come with me, and we will make short work, For by your leaves, you shall not stay alone Till Holy Church incorporates two in one.”

Read More

Friar Lawrence To Blame For The Deaths Of Romeo And Juliet

762 Words | 4 Pages

The nurse should have stopped Romeo and Juliet’s relationship. She should have interfered with their relationship because as Juliet’s nurse, she should have Juliet's best interest and be looking out for her. Instead of interfering, the nurse encouraged their relationship by keeping it a secret. The nurse warns Romeo not to deceive Juliet, but she never physically takes action to stop their relationship. Therefore, the nurse is also responsible for the tragedy of Romeo and

Read More

Nurse And Friar Lawrence In Shakespeare's Romeo And Juliet

516 Words | 3 Pages

“His name is Romeo, and a Montague; The only son of your great enemy”(Nurse). The Nurse helps her see Romeo even through she knew that the families hate each other. The Nurse helped Juliet see Romeo even through it was wrong so therefore the Nurse is also to be

Read More

Who Was To Blame For Romeo And Juliet's Death Essay

508 Words | 3 Pages

In William Shakespeare’s play Romeo and Juliet, Romeo is to blame for Romeo and Juliet’s death because he should’ve never been at the party to see Rosaline, he is also reckless. While some may argue that the Nurse is to blame for the deaths of Romeo and Juliet’s death because when she saw Romeo and Juliet kissing she decided not to tell their parents and make a plan to get together without the parents knowing. At the beginning of the play, Romeo is talking to a servant of the Capulet family. The servant doesn’t know that Romeo is a part of the Montague family that has been fighting for years. Within a scene in the play, Romeo is talking to the servant of the Capulet, he says “ Now I’ll tell you without asking.

Read More

The Nurse And Friar Lawrence In Shakespeare's 'Romeo And Juliet'

619 Words | 3 Pages

(Shakespeare 2.4 - 415). This quote shows the way the nurse receives the information right from Romeo to then take to Juliet. she does this multiple times and also can be seen basically planning some events like the marriage. The Nurse is the most important character for exchanging information between Romeo and Juliet due to her love for

Read More

Parental Guidance In Romeo And Juliet

1003 Words | 5 Pages

Romeo’s mother or father does not have any influence in his life, but Romeo’s friend did in place of theirs. Romeo’s friends did not show any parental support, unlike Juliet’s nurse. Juliet has the nurse to fill in as the role of her mother. Even though Juliet’s nurse gives Juliet guidance, the nurse has some boundaries because of her job. In addition to the nurse having boundaries with Juliet, Juliet seeks affection and attention since she does not always receive it from her parents.

Read More

Secret In Romeo And Juliet Essay

761 Words | 4 Pages

Not only did the nurse keep Romeo and Juliet’s forbidden love a secret, but she aided their blossoming love by delivering the messages in between the young lovers despite the fact that Romeo was a Montague, the enemy of the Capulets. “I will tell her, sir, that you do protest, which, as I take it,/ Is a gentlemanlike offer” (II.iv.153-154). The nurse is telling Romeo that she will inform Juliet of his plan to marry her in secret so they can be together without Juliet’s parents finding out, this leads to conflict later, as Juliet is being married off to Paris, but she is already married to Romeo, this situation causes her to fake her death, which Romeo thinks it’s real killing himself in his own grief. However this is not the only time the nurse helped with Romeo and Juliet’s relationship, after Romeo's banishment the nurse helps carry out the plan for Romeo and Juliet to meet once again “Hie to your chamber. I’ll find Romeo/ To comfort you” (III.ii.138-139).

Read More

Theme Of Loyalty In Romeo And Juliet

935 Words | 4 Pages

The Nurse helped out Juliet when her Parents could not. “As I told you my young lady bade me inquire you out; what she bade me say, I will keep to myself”(Act II.II.148-149). The Nurse has offered to keep the secret of the marriage between the two young ones and she will not tell anyone about it. After the Nursze comes back from visting Romeo she finds ways to not tell Juliet the good news instead she starts talking about other things, the Nurse also knows how delighted juliet will be once when she finds out about the wedding “Your love says, like an honest gentleman, and a courteous, and a kind,...where is your mother?”(Act II.II.55-57). The day of Mercutio and Tybalt 's death she did not think Romeo would do such a thing, and now her thoughts about Romeo have changed instead she thinks Romeo would end up hurting her young lady.

Read More

Comparative Essay: The Relationship Of Romeo And Juliet And Her Nurse

524 Words | 3 Pages

“Romeo and Juliet”Final Essay, The Relationship of Juliet And Her Nurse The relationship between Juliet and her Nurse portrayed in Romeo and Juliet has a different perspective from the classic young love genre. The Nurse is portrayed as loving as a parent,during her hardest times the Nurse gave motherly support and provided comfort from her confusion. Her Nurse appeared more in her time of trouble than her beloved Romeo and Lady Capulet. “Thou wast the prettiest babe that e’er I nursed.

Read More

Types Of Love In Romeo And Juliet

1472 Words | 6 Pages

Lastly, Shakespeare uses Romeo and Juliet to show true love. Nurse shows parental love to Juliet throughout the play. Despite being a servant to the Capulet household, she has a role equivalent to that of Juliet’s mothers and regards Juliet as her own. Even with the fact that Nurse is not the birth mother of Juliet, she still treats Juliet like a daughter. Nurse cares about Juliet and wants her to be happy and find success.”

Read More

More about What Extent Is The Nurse Responsible For The Deaths Of Romeo And Juliet Essay

Related Topics

Open Document