ipl-logo

A Brief Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke

960 Words4 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Landmark bakke v regents case conclude

In the case of Regents of the University of California v. Bakke, Allan Bakke a white male was rejected from regular admissions into California University. He was rejected twice; meanwhile, minority students with lower grade point averages were being admitted into the same school under a special admissions program. After his second rejection, Allan Bakke was very upset, so he filed a law suit to the Superior Court of Yolo County, California. He wanted the chance to be admitted into medical school through the special admissions program. The University said that their admissions program was important and it ought to be kept in the University. They said it helped with the issue of discrimination. In the past, minors were not admitted into medical …show more content…

He did not understand why he was not being admitted into the University while blacks, Asians, and other minorities were being excepted when they were plainly just not as smart as Allan. The lower court ruled that the special admissions program violated the state and federal constitutions and was illegal. Race should not be a deciding factor in the admissions process. But the lower court also ruled that Allan Bakke should not be admitted into the University of California because he failed regular admissions. Then the lower courts appealed the case to the Supreme Court. When the case was brought to the Supreme Court, the judges listened to both sides of the case. The Supreme Court judges with a vote of six to one decided that the special admissions program should be taken away and the Bakke should be admitted into medical school at the …show more content…

The University says that the special admissions program is for those minorities who aren’t smart enough to get in through the regular admissions. If they aren’t smart enough to get in through regular admissions, they should not be let into the school. We don’t want a black doctor to be a worse doctor than a white doctor just to have ethnic diversity in the medical fields. The lawyers also said that they have this special admissions program so that the medical world isn’t only made up of white doctors. But they said that minorities can make it into the school through regular admissions, so why would it be only white doctors? Our country should have only the best doctors, not just okay ones. I’m not saying that minority doctors will not be as good as white doctors, but there is always the chance because they didn’t get in through regular

Show More
Related

US V. San Francisco Unified School System

1090 Words | 5 Pages

PARTIES INVOLVED Kinney Kinmon Lau on behalf of the 1,800 non-English speaking students filed a suit against the San Francisco Unified School District. FACTS After a mandated integration of the San Francisco school system following a court order in 1971, a report was stated that in the San Francisco Unified School District there were approximately 2,800 students of Chinese decent in their school system that did not speak English. An estimated 1,000 students were receiving language support while the remaining 1,800 students were not receiving any additional support.

Read More

Jennifer Gratz V. Lee Bollinger Case Study

58 Words | 1 Pages

The case was Jennifer Gratz v Lee Bollinger. Jennifer Gratz, a caucasian women, applied to the University of Michigan College of Literature, Science, and the Arts (LSA) and got denied. The University of Michigan’s admission was based on a 100 point, point system. The University automatically awarded 20 points to students who were a member a minority

Read More

Bollinger V. Gratz Case Study

274 Words | 2 Pages

The second case filed against the University of Michigan is Grutter v. Bollinger (2003). The suit was filed by non-minority applicants who alleged the university for using race as the prevailing factor in admitting students and therefore violated the Equal Protection Clause, Title VI and Section 1981 (Green, 2004, p. 144). In their defense, the University of Michigan argued that the university seeks to ensure their ability to make unique contributions to the character of the student body by enrolling a “meaningful number” of underrepresented minority students (Green, 2004, p. 147). In contrast to the Gratz case, the district court did not follow Justice Powell’s rationale in the Bakke case and the district court ruled in favor of the plaintiff.

Read More

Supreme Court Case: Abigail Fisher V. University Of Texas

776 Words | 4 Pages

District Court judge, Sam Sparks, who upheld the university’s use of race when deciding admissions under the precedent of Grutter v. Bollinger because the university’s use of race was found to be narrowly tailored. When the decision was challenged, the case was heard by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit, and the district court’s ruling was affirmed. When Fisher challenged the decision, the case was heard by the Robert’s U.S. Supreme Court which decided that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit had erred by not applying the test of strict scrutiny to the University of Texas at Austin’s decision to base some of their admissions on race, and so the case went back to the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit. When the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit heard the case again, they decided that the university’s admission policy based somewhat on race was narrowly tailored to the objective of promoting educational diversity. Currently, the case Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin is pending a decision by the U.S. Supreme

Read More

Grutter V Bollinger Case Study

151 Words | 1 Pages

Issue- Can race diversity be taken into account when deciding admissions to a public University? Previous History- Grutter believed that the University was in violation of the Fourteenth Amendment, and of the Civil Rights Act.

Read More

Gregory G. Garre Esq's Oral Argument

182 Words | 1 Pages

Fisher v. University of Texas at Austin, No.14-981. Transcript of Gregory G. Garre Esq’s oral argument on behalf of the Respondent. Pg.51, lines 10-13, & Pg.55, lines 7-9: Back in 2002, from a class of 8,000, there were only 272 black students enrolled; 90% of the time, it is typical for a normal size classroom of to have zero to one African American student. Id. General Donald B. Verrilli, Jr. agrees that in the event of two applicants’ criteria are exact alike, their race factors does “not necessary” matter in the admission office’s decision making. “The increasingly fierce competition for the decreasing number of seats available for Texas students outside the top 10% rule results in minority students being under-represented, and

Read More

The Case Of West Central Dixie State University V. The Sons Of The Confederacy

2066 Words | 9 Pages

Because there are two cases involved, there are two different legal questions that we must answer. First, we were to answer whether The Asian Society’s and its members Equal Protection rights were abridged upon by them being denied the benefits of the other minorities that attend West Central Dixie State University. Secondly, we were to answer the question brought to the court by The Sons of the Confederacy: Is the policy of positive segregation implemented by the university unconstitutional based on the rights guaranteed in the Fourteenth Amendment, specifically the Equal Protection clause. We agree with the lower Court’s ruling in the case of The Asian Society that the policy itself it not unconstitutional, but that it does violate the Fourteenth Amendment because the compelling interest of the university is not narrowly-tailored enough. It should include all minorities not just some for the policy of positive segregation to fulfill its purpose of multiculturalism and diversity.

Read More

What Is The Case Of Mississippi University For Women V. Hogan Case Study

915 Words | 4 Pages

In the case, Mississippi University for Women v. Hogan, the respondent Joe Hogan, who attempted to enroll to the MUW’s School of Nursing, was denied admission (“Mississippi University for,” n.d.). The website, informs that the reason why he was denied enrollment for credit in the School of Nursing, is was created the controversy of whether the decision of the university was a violation to the Equal Protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment. The United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit reached to a conclusion after analyzing deeply if the reason that the state had to deny enrollment to Hogan had a reasonable justification. The court’s decision could impact and create changes in the educational system in the Mississippi University

Read More

Summary Of The Fisher V. University Of Texas Supreme Court Case

572 Words | 3 Pages

The Fisher v. University of Texas Supreme Court Case (argued in 2015) involves how race affects college admissions and how a certain student reacted to it. The purpose of the article is to inform the audience about the use of race in college admissions without considering the effect on the students. The argument made in the article is that the documentation of race does not violate any laws declared in the United States Constitution (“Fisher v. University of Texas”). A white female student, Abigail Fisher, was denied admission to the University of Texas because she did not qualify for the Top Ten Percent Plan.

Read More

Case Study Of Brown V. Topeka Board Of Education

830 Words | 4 Pages

The problem that the Supreme Court was facing was whether the equal protection clause of the Fourteenth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution mandates the states to desegregate in the public schools, which means the policy of “separate but equal” that those states followed is unconstitutional or not. Morally, segregation is unacceptable, but it was difficult to justify the idea legally under the 14th amendment because the defense lawyer claimed that the issue was about the control of public schools, it should be the “states” right issue that Congress was not intended to be covered by the 14th amendment. Until the second extensive discussion, the newly appointed Justice Warren noticed the policy, and Warren Court had agreed that segregation was inequitable and unconstitutional. However, he considered that in this case, it is very important to reach unanimous. So he wrote an opinion for dissenting justices to convince them to reach the significance unanimous, and finally, Warren court made a 9-0 unanimous decision that “separate educational facilities are fundamentally

Read More

Case Study Of Brown V. Board Of Topeka Kansas

852 Words | 4 Pages

This complaint case consisted of thirteen plaintiffs and twenty students who were forbidden from attending public schools with whites. The group filed a complaint to the board with the intention of changing the rule of segregation between colored and whites. Their complaint was seen unreasonable and the court found itself leaning towards the side of the Board of Education. This was because the schools were seen equally fair in terms of classroom settings, the staff, quality of education provided, etc. However, it still appeared unconstitutional because of content stated in the 14th amendment, which consists of the rights of the citizens and an equal amount of protection of the laws.

Read More

Plessy Vs Ferguson Research Paper

688 Words | 3 Pages

In Regents of University of California v. Bakke (1978), the Supreme Court ruled that a university 's use of racial "quotas" in its admissions process was unconstitutional, but a school 's use of "affirmative action" to accept more minority applicants was constitutional in some circumstances. " The college was asked to at least consider blacks in the admittance of college and they were asked to not use quotas in the admission

Read More

Abigal N. Fisher Case Analysis

325 Words | 2 Pages

In 2008, Abigal N. Fisher, a caucasian female, applied as a undergrad student at University of Texas at Austin, but was denied admissions. UT admissions policy has a top 10% rule which means, the first top 10% of high school graduates are automatically admitted. Fisher was not in this 10% category and was not admitted based on this rule. UT bases its admission decision partially based on race of the applicant. Based on this consideration, Fisher believes she was denied because of her race.

Read More

Hopwood Vs Texas

1199 Words | 5 Pages

The Supreme Court has not offered an opinion on affirmative action in higher education since its 1978 ruling in Regents of the Univ. Of California v. Bakke. In that determination, the Supreme Courts Justice Powell argued that a university could take race into account as one among a number of factors in student admissions for the purposed of achieving student body diversity. Since the time of this ruling, affirmative action programs with regard to student admissions, financial assistance, and even faculty employment have been founded mainly on achieving diversity. Since the Bakke decision, affirmative action has been an increasingly contentious issue between those in favor of its employment and those opposed to it.

Read More

Essay On Discrimination In College Admissions

672 Words | 3 Pages

Many students feel that in order to add diversity into their campus many schools are willing to overlook less desired GPA 's, ACT, and SAT scores. One example that shows how schools favor minorities is the story of Vijay Chokal-Ingam who is Indian-American. Vijay wanted to get into medical school. After witnessing his Indian-American friend fall victim to the use of racial

Read More

More about A Brief Case Of Regents Of The University Of California V. Bakke

Open Document