ipl-logo

CIPA Code Of Ethics Paper

1341 Words6 Pages

The utilization of internet filters in public libraries throughout the United States has become ubiquitous. This technology prevents public library users from accessing certain websites. Its primary goal is to limit children’s exposure to potentially harmful visual content. Like many other new technologies, its usage is controversial and has led to much ethical debate. This papers performs an ethical analysis of this technology examining both sides of the argument. The ethical standard used for this evaluation is the Association of Computing and Machinery (ACM) Code of Ethics. This paper is organized as follows. Section 2 provides background information including the history of internet filters and an explanation of the specific imperatives …show more content…

This federal initiative began in 1996 and has significantly increased internet access in public institutions in rural and underserved areas across the United States [1]. In December 2000, the United States Congress enacted the Children’s Internet Protection (CIPA). The objective of this law is to protect from children from potentially harmful online material by requiring the recipients of E-Rate funds, namely public libraries and schools, to implement “technology protection measures” [1]. CIPA defines a “technology protection measure” as a technology that blocks internet websites with visual depictions that are: obscene, children pornography, or harmful to minors [1]. CIPA only calls for restriction on visual content such as images and not …show more content…

ETHICAL ARGUMENTS AGAINST THE USE OF THE INTERNET FILTERS As mentioned in the preceding section, CIPA affects both public libraries and schools. This ethical analysis will focus specifically on the ethical implications of use of internet filters in public libraries. This is the ethical action that will be tested. Because public libraries are used by both children and adults, there are far greater ethical issues with web filters in libraries than schools, where computers are used almost exclusively by minors. The ethical actors in this analysis include public library administrators who have direct control over the implementation of internet filters. Elected officials such as those in Congress are also the ethical actors because they can vote on laws that affect the use of internet filters. Congress is directly responsible for the widespread implementation of internet filters as a consequence of CIPA. The main ethical arguments that oppose internet filters are the following: restriction on adult access to free speech, underblocking, and overblocking. 3.1 Restriction on Adult Access to Free

Show More
Related

Is 1984 A Totalitarian Government

533 Words | 3 Pages

"Imagine a world where the government, whether it is federal, state, or local, has the power to monitor internet content. In more ways than one, can this sort of government be compared to the fictitious totalitarian government portrayed in George Orwell's 1984; a world in which specific things are censored to instill certain beliefs into the masses. This sort of government is obviously abominable. But also, imagine a government that allows too much freedom on the Internet that will lead to bullying and other various crimes. This essay will talk about to what extent the government has the duty to monitor the Internet content.

Read More

Arguments Against CIPA

973 Words | 4 Pages

It seems the initial purpose of CIPA was to prevent minors from accessing pornography in libraries; this is fine, as I am sure that no librarian wants to try to advocate for the right to provide minors access to pornography. However, the act also stated that the filters were to help protect minors from accessing content, other than pornography, that is considered harmful to them. This is where the situation gets complicated; it appears that the federal government is requiring us to choose between funding and violating the first amendment right of our patrons. By censoring the internet content our minor patrons are allowed to access we are placing more importance on funding than on our patrons and their

Read More

Pros And Cons Of Net Neutrality

805 Words | 4 Pages

Though the internet is often considered a vestibule for open conversations, there is some illusion to the matter. It isn’t all bad, of course, as we can use email and search filters to keep things from sight if we so choose, such as spam filters or Google’s safe search. The problem appears when (Cox, 2010) “censored material goes well beyond offensive material and includes a great deal of political information and opinion, especially debates about international issues such as wars and human rights violations”. If this is what has already been going on, it should bring up concerns about what may happen in the future if the current rules and regulations are

Read More

Essay On Why The Government Should Limit The First Amendment

800 Words | 4 Pages

"To define the government's role in internet content, we must first understand our constitution and what it allows. Right in the Bill of Rights, the 1st Amendment, free speech. To this country, there is nothing more important than that right. Without it, we wouldn’t be the country we are today. In wake of all of the negativity surrounding free speech, no one quite realizes what the bigger picture it about it.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Banning Books

261 Words | 2 Pages

At the start of this investigation I had a clear opinion about banning books. I believed that no book should be banned, by anyone, and that public libraries should provide every possible information for the readers, as it was their duty. As I kept reading the points that supported my opinion, this one grew stronger, until I investigated the other side of the argument, where points as to why books should be banned were given. Now, that I have read that part, I realize that there is much more to the simple answer of “books shouldn’t be banned” So, my conclusion to this research is that with the diverse opinions and morals that exist in our world the books that have been banned have been done for a reason.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Federal Censorship

1377 Words | 6 Pages

One of the major problems that arise from any type of censorship is the way it negatively affects the citizens of the US. A great deal of censorship is seen online from the federal government and private companies alike. One way the federal government has censored private companies online is fines for if a platform is used for adult interaction. This act preventing this interaction is helpful for the general public, but an entire industry felt a hit (“Censorship”). Online communication made many of the “adult” workers safer and prerecord while working.

Read More

Should First Amendment Be Allowed In Schools

1255 Words | 6 Pages

Common curriculum in Schools teach students their first amendment rights however schools themselves take the steps to block public information on computers that students should be able to access. Public schools teach Constitutional rights in America, yet every school uses Internet blocker programs the prevent students’ free access to information. All public schools are required to teach a civics class yet these schools restrict the first amendment from students on the Internet. A common debate is whether or not schools should be allowed to censor information posted on the internet from their students. Students have the right to freedom of the press even if that means the information is biased or otherwise “classified” harmful.

Read More

Issues With CIPA

1444 Words | 6 Pages

The conflict between CIPA and Library authority After computer was invented, the thing called internet appeared. Today, more and more people are using internet to search information and chat with others. Especially, young people love to surf internet to find new friends and discover new knowledge. Of course, they may find out something sexual and obscene.

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Democracy In The United States

743 Words | 3 Pages

We are living in a digital era.   More than ever before, the internet is used to meet friends, make shopping convenient, produce alternate forms of education, just to name a few of the mundane activities that are being quickly digitized.   Currently the issue of net neutrality is being hotly debated in Congress, but it is more than an issue of internet prices, it is an issue of freedom, gender discrimination, and the attempt to monopolize our thoughts.

Read More

Censorship Should Be Banned In Schools

1915 Words | 8 Pages

It is not shocking that the most challenges and bans come from parents of younger students. “The vast majority of challenges to reading material, according to the American Library Association (ALA), are made by parents. School and university libraries, public libraries, classrooms, and businesses across the nation see attempts to ban books on a regular, if not frequent, basis; Joan Bertin, executive director of the National Coalition Against Censorship, said she encounters an attempt at book-banning or censorship every week. Banned books range from contemporary bestsellers to centuries-old classics, from fictional narratives to historical and biographical nonfiction, and from children’s fairy tales to adult erotica.” Schools and their libraries are usually the ones who have to deal with the bans and challenges.

Read More

Final Essay

919 Words | 4 Pages

Internet censorship should always take place and the internet regulations should be implemented for three certain reasons. First, restricted Information is either inappropriate or dangerous. MUTHAMA(2013) mentioned that, internet regulations for users and service providers are important to protect access to illegal information. Second, governments try to provide protection for online users as well as providing more internet access. Schell (2014) mentioned that, government leaders and citizens adopt support for the concept of internet freedom.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of E-Censorship

1047 Words | 5 Pages

E-censorship: Selection or censorship? E-censorship and self-censorship are being practiced in public schools and public libraries across the United States, this is a danger to our rights as citizens and free thinkers. The blame of this active infringement on our personal rights, was thought as governmental overreach due to certain mandates, but this action tends to fall on those in charge of such filtering within the institutions. Educators and institutions often claim that it is a requirement from the federal government, as well as a process as to not offend different viewpoints, however who’s viewpoint is the right one in this instance? Throughout history there have been many instances where the opinions of others spill over into what should or shouldn’t take place within public institutions.

Read More

The Pros And Cons Of Censorship In Schools

500 Words | 2 Pages

Censorship used in schools is justified, because it ensures that internet use is appropriate for the school setting, and in particular the eyes of young children. Some libraries may use censorship in order to block access to certain web pages, including pornography, advertising, chat, gaming, social networking, and online forum sites, because pages such as these, may be considered unsafe for some users that could potentially access the internet from the library. Companies may use censorship in order to control what websites their employees may view on their internet during the time that they should be working. Such censorship would be beneficial, because it would ensure that employees are remaining productive and not using the internet for activities like social media, games, or other

Read More

Internet Censorship In The United States

2000 Words | 8 Pages

Both arguments either for or against Internet censorship have strong reasons for their different beliefs, and each equally present their arguments through their own research of what they believe is the best for their country. The first and most prevalent argument shown in each is the appeal of emotional standpoint. When presented by the anti-internet censorship population, the use of children and keeping them safe and secure online has a very strong emotional aspect. On the other hand, the blocking of some sites does little to help the child and may actually be detrimental to their education. Another argument is the belief that a country can help themselves look better than they actually are.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On Censorship In Schools

1758 Words | 8 Pages

“As the world enters the 21st century, the access to information and freedom of speech provided by the Internet and other digital technologies have revolutionized the nature of censorship challenges and opened an entirely new realm of legal and social ramifications for censorship in United States schools” (Simmons and Dresang Back Cover). Likewise, the increasing role of the more traditional varieties of expression, such as that of free speech, literature, and choice of clothing, coupled with the new ideas stemming from the modern digital revolution, continue to push back on attempts to censor. The Fairfax County Public Schools system, along with school systems all over the country, has employed the use of various censorship over the years, under the justification of safeguarding the interests of students and faculty members alike. However, many feel as though their civil liberties are being infringed upon by the school and other governing bodies at play. Nevertheless, censorship in all of its forms is discernibly fashioning strain on the daily lives of students and teachers,

Read More

More about CIPA Code Of Ethics Paper

Open Document