ipl-logo

Comparing Dennett's 'Tower Of Generate And Test'

635 Words3 Pages

Kayla Southworth
Professor Nichols
Paper 1
September 28, 2015
The plasticity of differences In the piece “Tower of Generate and Test” by philosopher Dan Dennett, he talks about creatures and the characteristics that make them that certain kind of creature. Dennett goes about doing this by setting the piece up in an hierarchy pattern where the base is Darwinian creatures which builds up to Skinnerian creatures and Popperian creatures. Now while, Dennett makes the claim that Skinnerian creatures and Popperian creatures are subcategories of Darwinian creatures, when he goes on to explain the respective subcategory it becomes evident that they differ from Darwinian creatures. They differ in that they contain phenotypic plasticity in their behavior on different levels based on their placement in the tower with one containing a learning capability and the other containing a gene that internally allows them to know the outcome beforehand, while Darwinian creatures do not contain these types of capabilities. Dennett presents the idea of phenotypic plasticity in the Skinnerian creatures when he talks about reinforces on page 85. It is in this section, that he talks about …show more content…

These types of creatures do not contain this because the creature if they were to need to change their behavior they would not be able to causing for their demise as they would not be able to adapt to the changes needed due to the predetermined gene they contain (Dennett 84). It is from those predetermined genes that it can indeed be concluded that Darwinian creatures do in fact differ from Skinnerian and Popperian creatures.

Work cited
Dennett, Daniel. "The Tower of Generate and Test." Kinds of Minds. New York: Basic, 1996. 81-93.

Show More
Related
755 Words | 4 Pages

For instance, bears have evolved from scary animals that humans feared, to cuddly “teddy bears”. Some may ask how or why this is the case and there are certainly piles of evidence to support this statement. To begin, the bear itself was turned into a “teddy bear” named after Teddy Roosevelt because he could not shoot a bear. In this book, a man named Kelsey Eliasson was “turned off by the way he saw activists like Polar Bears International “Disney-fying” the bear”.

Read More
1156 Words | 5 Pages

Overall, Darwin knew that species were transforming and evolving over

Read More
810 Words | 4 Pages

But psychologists like Henry Goddard were the judge, jury, and executioner when determining the criteria for feeblemindedness. Even the most fickle factors were applied as Goddard believed in “the unmistakable look of the feebleminded” and that “just a glance sufficed” at making that

Read More
1385 Words | 6 Pages

Skinners experiment was based on operant conditioning, using the concept of discrimination learning, he carried out experiments on animals with the idea that their behaviour is predetermined by their environment and using a well controlled environment would allow him to in turn control their behaviours using a range of triggers. Using reinforcement and expectancy, the animal associates acting out certain behaviours with rewards. (Toates, F., 2010, pp. 165-167) After performing a number of experiments on rats using mazes, he subsequently designed the Skinner box.

Read More
743 Words | 3 Pages

I argue that while mechanistic and teleological explanations are distinctly different, both are required in order to thoroughly explain a phenomenon. In this essay, I will describe mechanistic, atomistic, and teleological explanations, highlight their key differences, and then explain why one cannot completely understand a phenomenon without incorporating a teleological component. A mechanistic explanation is one that describes “how” a phenomenon (such as breathing, growing, or eating) occurs. It conveys the physiological, or physical, movements and changes involved in that phenomenon.

Read More
1269 Words | 6 Pages

Title Abstract 150 Introduction500 405 Personality is a range of correlated behaviours that are expressed in different contexts. Animals exhibit behavioural syndromes, which is a set of behaviours seen in multiple scenarios. (huntingford 1976 as read in Pelligrini et al., 2010)..Find this!. An example of a behavioural syndrome is the shy/bold continuum (i.e. proactive-reactive) (Wilson et al., 1994 as read in Pellegrini et al., 2010). Boldness has been studied in many species.

Read More
1261 Words | 6 Pages

Paper 1: BEHAVIOR MODIFICATION Becky Templin Clovis Community College February 17, 2018 Introduction The theory behind behavior modification ethics has a reputation for its accomplishments and disappointments. In addition to this, there are many dangers in using physical punishment as behavior modification with the two primary modifiers of behavior being Classical conditioning and Operant conditioning. The outcome of using negative reinforcement has its share of benefits and downfalls in human behavior whereas; positive reinforcement seems to win over.

Read More
1006 Words | 5 Pages

This was in stark contrast to behaviorists who believed that behavior was the product of the environment and its consequences

Read More
464 Words | 2 Pages

He points out that so-called pain-behaviour is neither necessary nor sufficient for the experience of pain. It is not necessary because the best policy in some instances might be to not show that they are in pain. It is not sufficient since amoebas engage in pain behaviour, but we do not believe that they can feel pain. Likewise, we could easily program robots to engage in pain-behaviour, but we would not conclude that they feel pain. The similarity of animal and human physical structures is inconclusive because we have no idea how, or even if, the physical structure of human beings gives rise to experiences in the first place.

Read More
1292 Words | 6 Pages

It is undeniable that the foundation of Wilhelm Wundt’s Institute of Experimental Psychology and the introduction of Darwin’s new theory of evolution as descried in Origin of Species has had a huge impact on the development of the modern discipline of Psychology and on society today. In this essay I will examine Wilhelm Wundt’s Institute of Experimental Psychology and Darwin’s theory of evolution from Origin of Species. I will look at what they included and the effect they had on Psychology and society at the time they were published and their influence years after. Firstly I will assess the impact of the new theory of evolution as described in Darwin’s Origin of Species.

Read More
1126 Words | 5 Pages

Introduction The theory of evolution has been discussed, evaluated, and researched many times since the theory was first brought to light. Darwin’s theory of evolution is said to be divided into two parts, common decent and natural selection (Bouzat, 2014). Many research papers agreeing with Darwin’s theory comment on the diversity of a species and how they have descended from one common ancestor. Natural selection is a process in which species that are better adapted to the environment tend to survive and reproduce (Dictonary.com).

Read More
1387 Words | 6 Pages

Hamna Iqbal Baig Ms. Maria Kamal English Writing Skills November 26th, 2014 Outline Nature vs. Nurture Thesis statement: Nurture dominates nature in determining gender roles. Gender roles are socially constructed and are acquired through the process of socialization. . Nature is a key determinant of gender roles.

Read More
1114 Words | 5 Pages

1. B.F. Skinner: Behaviour modification Positive and negative reinforcements or rewards and punishments are used to modify or shape learner’s behaviour. B. F. Skinner’s entire system is based on operant conditioning. The organism is in the process of "operating" on the environment, which in ordinary terms means it is bouncing around its world, doing what it does. During this "operating," the organism encounters a special kind of stimulus, called a reinforcing stimulus, or simply a reinforcer.

Read More
650 Words | 3 Pages

Dr. Dweck was able to confirm the different thinking processes that people with different mindsets

Read More
625 Words | 3 Pages

One of the most well known theories in cognitive development is Piaget 's theory. The psychologist Jean Piaget theorized that as children 's minds development, they pass through distinct stages marked by transitions in understanding followed by stability. Piaget describes four different stages of development: sensorimotor, preoperational, concrete operation, and formal operations. Each stage describes the thinking patterns of a child depending on his or her age. In order to compare the thinking processes of a three-year old and a nine-year old using Piaget 's theory, you must compare two sequential stages of cognitive development: preoperational and concrete operations.

Read More

More about Comparing Dennett's 'Tower Of Generate And Test'

Related Topics

Open Document