ipl-logo

Comparing Ellsberg And The Vietnam War

803 Words4 Pages

Similar to Assange and Snowden, Ellsberg can only be considered heroic for his actions of releasing Pentagon papers amidst the Vietnam War to inform the American public about the real ongoings of the war. US Citizens have a right to information therefore the US government must respect that right and tell them exactly what is happening during the war, even its negative, embarrassing, aspects. The Vietnam War was arguably one of America’s greatest military failures and part of the reason it was such a failure was because of President Nixon and Defense Secretary McNamaras’ repeated lies that things were going well, that America was making “progress” in fighting communism in Vietnam. Ellsberg really changed the course of the Vietnam War, by helping Americans realize it was a lost cause and that the US government and military were lying to the press and thus violating the First Amendment of the Constitution. …show more content…

Ellsberg really was the original whistleblower, setting up a precedent for Assange and Snowden to follow as they too decided to release classified documents for the wellbeing of American citizens. As Ellsberg rightly states, “such leaks remain the lifeblood of a free press and our republic”(CWI Sources). The US was founded on freedom of speech and the press by our founding fathers who revolted against Great Britain because they were prevented from having those basic human rights. Furthermore, Ellsberg’s trial for violating the Espionage Act of 1917 proved how corrupt the US government and CIA were as they violated Ellsberg’s Fourth and Fifth Amendments to land a conviction, but failed, thus leading to a mistrial and all charges dropped. By releasing these Pentagon documents, Ellsberg revamped US citizens’ constitutional rights, making Ellsberg a true

Show More
Related
1185 Words | 5 Pages

WikiLeaks has released numerous documents “to bring important news and information to the public” so that “readers and historians alike can see evidence of the truth (What is WikiLeaks, 1). ” There are numerous reports on the imprisonment of journalists within the United States who have released government information to the public. This website provides a platform for journalists and the like to supply government information to the public that would otherwise be kept from them. Due to the Bill of Rights in the United States Constitution that allows freedom of the press, Congress is unable to pass a law that would prevent WikiLeaks from providing such information to constituents. The United States government, however, is presently trying to terminate the WikiLeaks website and is encouraging search engines to prevent the WikiLeaks website from appearing in their searches.

Read More
59 Words | 1 Pages

Being an Intelligence Analyst in the military, Chelsea Manning’s job was to handle classified information, but she discovered documents that revealed atrocities committed by the US in Iraq. Feeling compelled to let people know what was happening in the Global War on Terror, she promptly released this sensitive information to a website known as Wikileaks for all to see.

Read More
289 Words | 2 Pages

Henry Kissinger, Secretary of State and National Security Advisor, along with President Nixon believed that it would be in the best interest of the United States to keep the Cambodian bombings a secret. Former President Lyndon B. Johnson had been public about his involvement in Vietnam, which did not completely bode well for him. Protests and riots errupte as a result of Johnson’s exposure of war efforts. For these reasons, Nixon decided to keep all his Cambodia plans within a small circle of his trusted advisors. Before 1863, Cambodia mainly served as a vassal territory for either the Thai or Vietnamese governments' to own.

Read More
518 Words | 3 Pages

For example, Edward Snowden exposed the National Security Agency for eavesdropping on Americans and people around the world, despite the possibility of being arrested and charged with heavy crimes. " So, what did the leaks tell us? First, they confirmed that the U.S. government, without obtaining any court warrants, routinely collects the phone logs of tens of millions, perhaps hundreds of millions, of Americans, who have no links to terrorism whatsoever,"(Source 3). The question is who is truly at fault? The government for doing that or Snowden for ratting them out to the public about

Read More
427 Words | 2 Pages

He donated lots of money to people and places and charities that needed it the most . This would be one reason why someone would think he is heroic. Many people would not really see this heroic because he was a wealthy man he had a lot more money than what he donated. Yes he did donate a good portion of his money but people

Read More
249 Words | 1 Pages

I don 't think of Edward Snowden as a hero or a traitor. I do think what he did was bad he informed the general public of what the federal government is doing and the people have the right to know. If my best friend 's girlfriend was cheating on him and I told him about it does that make me a traitor? that 's an over simplified comparison but the point is that we as people of the "free world" have the right to know. The federal government should not have the ability to monitor your activity without a warrant without a just cause.

Read More
2406 Words | 10 Pages

The Article kept true to the facts but Mark Felt was a hero, a patriot an original Edward Snowden who did the right thing even against something that was bigger than

Read More
1280 Words | 6 Pages

Snowden was committed to doing the right thing so he revealed the different spying operations that were going on within the N.S.A. He became a whistleblower who rescued American citizens from being monitored through illegal surveillance and was looked upon as a

Read More
1231 Words | 5 Pages

Humanity constantly evolves and learns from previous mistakes, but only for a short while. Speaker Amity Shlaes stated, "Nothing is new, it is just forgotten. Everything we contemplate now, has been contemplated before… We just do not remember or choose to remember. " By reflecting on the Sixties, as was done during the third Center for Constructive Alternatives, one is able to halt the cycle of "forgetting" and instead grow as a logical being. By reflecting, one chooses to remember, and therefore, if enough members of a society choose to learn from the past, then a society or country will grow and become better for future generations.

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

Snowden took some of the files out of the millions he had and gave that information to the media for them to do a story on it (Epstein A.11.)2. The information he stole should’ve been handed over as well with Snowden. The people who kept him from the United States should be prosecuted. Snowden kept information in his head for the reason if he needed leverage to get out of a situation. Snowden said with being the most wanted

Read More
241 Words | 1 Pages

In 2013, Edward Snowden rose to prominence after he released classified documents to the public regarding the existence of United States (US) government’s wide spread surveillance programs conducted through the National Security Agency (NSA). Snowden is an American computer expert, a former Central Intelligence Agency (CIA) systems administrator and NSA subcontractor. On one hand, Snowden had been called a traitor and charged with violating the Espionage Act of 1917 and committing treason by the US government for leaking state secrets, whereas on the other, he has been hailed as a hero by many for his actions. He currently resides under temporary asylum in Russia and continues to speak about his work. He has brought the issue of whistleblowing

Read More
1755 Words | 8 Pages

WikiLeaks: An Ethical Synthesis Since November of2010, WikiLeaks has held the controversial position of being the world's foremost digital whistleblower haven. The site, founded and orchestrated by Julian Assange, has made a mission of exposing the underbelly of international political, military, and social operations. In pursuit of this mission, the site routinely publishes sensitive government materials, earning it a reputation of ruthless dedication to transparency. In doing so, however, it has endangered a number of individuals and the relationships between the international actors that are vital to the stability of global politics. Because of this, many argue that the mission of WikiLeaks, while just in its intention, is unjustifiably

Read More
1924 Words | 8 Pages

Unfortunately, that is not the case with WikiLeaks because the information is accessed in a manner that is not known or clear and no one can be traced to show where the information originated. Thus, the ethical issue that WikiLeaks has is whether it is doing the right thing by providing information that states would have preferred to be confidential and whether the information is beneficial to the public. The current society is perceived to be free, and thus, people in a free society need to know the truth despite the fact that the truth becomes treason. Thus, the existence of an organization such as WikiLeaks is that it is incredibly beneficial to the society.

Read More
714 Words | 3 Pages

Dystopia is an imagined place where everything is degraded, and the condition is bad. In the materials we have covered, dystopia was created either with the use of technology of with the use of totalitarianism. Many times, totalitarianism is justified with the purpose of having a stable government and technology is justified by making things easier for the people. These two have their own similarities and differences in terms of dystopian discourses that reflect the contemporary fears of what could happen in the future.

Read More
1471 Words | 6 Pages

He put his whole life and career at risk by being a whistleblower. He was able to divulge to the public the illegal activities of the NSA in the collection of many private information transmitted through the internet. His intention was to inform everyone about the violation of the NSA in the rights of every internet user for freedom. This so-called “internet- and telecommunications-liberty” was deprived when the US government launched the PRISM

Read More

More about Comparing Ellsberg And The Vietnam War

Related Topics

Open Document