ipl-logo

Comparing Foucault's Discipline And Punish

793 Words4 Pages

Genevieve Decoteau
Professor Guili
12/12/14
Philosophy 73 - Final Paper Foucault's Discipline and Punish is mainly about the history of the modern prison system. It was analyzed to examine the power that effects punishment and how crimes are problematic. The reformation of punishment were not motivated by the concerns of the welfare of the prisoners. " Punishment, if I may so put it should strike the soul rather than the body", meaning punishment strikes the inner person and not the body. The power to punish is not essentially a difference from that of curing or educating the normalized discipline society. Foucault believed that prison being very closely linked with many of the structures of society was the soul of the prison body, meaning the soul is the key. The structure and the mechanism where prisoners are disciplined is …show more content…

The prison systems performs a critical function in modern society. David J Rothman states " The ultimate purpose of the prison, Foucault declares is to divide the outlaw from the proletariat, thereby reducing lower class solidarity and protest", meaning it separates the worst criminals from the least dangerous criminals. Criminals were made in prison! Everyone in prison are potentially a criminal everyone has the same characteristics but different judgements. Prison don't diminish crime rate, they increases it. Prison intends to give pain, to cure, to comfort , and to exercise a power of normalization for the

Show More
Related

Summary Of Reamer's On The Parole Board

2123 Words | 9 Pages

Prisons were created to keep out the bad and abnormal that were disturbing society, but over time urbanization and capitalism advanced prisons into working factories. Prisons are a way for people to reflect on the decisions that they have made. In Chapter 5, Redemption and Hope, Reamer reflects of the different ways prisoner’s coup with being released on parole. Surprisingly, there are many inmates that get released and commit another crime and are sent right back in because they violate their probation. However, there are the lucky ones who make it out and stay out.

Read More

Who Is Pascal Emmanuel-Gobry's Abolish Prison?

161 Words | 1 Pages

The general argument made by author Pascal Emmanuel-Gobry his work “Abolish Prison”, is that he believes the reason of the prison is very stupid and weird to punish a criminal. More specifically, Pascal argue that there should be no reason for prison, because it is very inhumane way to punish crime. He also argues that prison is just a multitude of criminals that are place in location that looks like a box surrounding by dysfunctional people. This cause can cause an effect of paranoia and a lot sexual misconduct due to the fact that men are surrounding by other men not by women's. He writes, “Prison is an incredibly stupid way to fight crime because, as is well known, it is the enemy of rehabilitation” and also “Everybody know that it's endemic

Read More

Rhetorical Analysis Of Even Prisoners Must Have Hope By Richard Stratton

237 Words | 1 Pages

In the article “Even Prisoners Must Have Hope”, Richard Stratton (the author) talks about his thoughts on the federal prison system in America. Stratton himself had served 8 years in jail for smuggling marijuana. He strongly advises not to make the prisons even worse than they already are. The harsh conditions and other peoples’ vengeful attitudes toward criminals only make the violence and crime continue. According to Stratton, instead of improving the harsh conditions and trying to rehabilitate and help prisoners that could lead to peace, our society inflicts more pain and punishment, enforcing a violent cycle.

Read More

Analysis Of Why Prisons Don T Work By Wilbert Rideau

545 Words | 3 Pages

Today’s court and justice systems, as well as our prison system, are flawed and don’t do enough to not only hinder any further crime from occurring, but put those who may cause further complications in our society in jail. In the article “Why Prisons Don’t Work,” Wilbert Rideau, a murderer sentenced to life in jail, explains his reasons and provides evidence on why our prison system is counterproductive. According to Rideau, many of those who are thrown in prison, were convicted due to their unskilled, impulsive, and uneducated actions. Putting these men in prison may seem like a good idea, but there are underlying reasons why prisons don’t work.

Read More

Persuasive Essay On 3 Strike Law

493 Words | 2 Pages

Criminals are not allows willing to change and most of them always end up going back to their same routines and crimes over and over again. By placing those criminals in jail, it lets society put a stop to ever

Read More

Rehabilitation In Shawshank's Redemption

766 Words | 4 Pages

First you hate them, then you get used to them. Enough time passes, you get so you depend on them. That 's institutionalized.’ A prison should aim at retribution, incapacitation, deterrence and rehabilitation. I am very well convinced that prison has served its first three purposes by depriving offenders’ freedom, but the

Read More

Punishment And The History Of Prison Reform Summary

787 Words | 4 Pages

which are often linked to very high rates of incarceration. Critical social theory challenges ideologies and offers a better framework for creating a more equal and just society. To discuss the limitations of moral theories in addressing the complex issues of the prison system, it is important to note that moral theories of punishment have historically not been the best vehicle for addressing the prison crisis. Traditional moral justifications of punishment, like those presented in mainstream philosophy, often fall short in providing effective solutions to the challenges faced in the penal system. Moral theories may critique current penal institutions and practices, but they may not offer practical guidance for designing alternatives or for creating positive social change in the system.

Read More

Prison Industrial Abolition

1642 Words | 7 Pages

The creation of prisons were established around the time of the emancipation of slavery. The black community were released from the horrific life they faced when living in slavery, but slavery was not over. Once the African American’s were free society configured a plan that would put an end to the freedom of slaves. The creation of prisons, allowed society the ability to enact a formal genocide of black people by placing them in cages. The roles of prisons over time as established locations that conduct inhuman treatment of Americans, primarily those who are colored, immigrants and other communities labeled as inferior to whites.

Read More

Analyzing Foucault's Punishment Customs

261 Words | 2 Pages

During the nineteenth century and part of the late eighteenth century, the article “Panopicism” indicates Foucault began to analyze the transition in the prison’s punishment customs. Beginning in the early 1700’s there has been a transition from torture to a more rationalized and humane way of punishing prisoners (rehabilitation, rules and discipline). Torture occurs after the bad deed has happened and only so much can be administered before death occurs. With the new way of punishment, people have transitioned into a less likelihood of even committing crime or breaking the law due to the new punishment’s deterring qualities and the rules can be taught and retaught (Soc. 436 class notes 2017).

Read More

Comparing Foucault's 'Discipline And Punish'

533 Words | 3 Pages

These abstract constraints subconciously impact even our new ways of thinking. Throughout the text Foucault later refers to power as it is related to punishment. He states “in the late eighteenth century one is confronted by three ways of organizing the power to punish.” The three methods varied in the ways of how the human body would be affected whether it be through physical or

Read More

Michel Foucault Discipline And Punish Analysis

1356 Words | 6 Pages

Michel Foucault, Discipline and Punish: The Birth of the Prison Wanchen Xie Introduction on the author Michel Foucault was born on October 15, 1926 in Poitiers, France. He wrote a great many works which influenced the philosophy and sociology deeply, for instance, Madness and Civilization. Not only was Foucault an intellectual and philosopher, but he was a political activist as well. He got involved in various protests and campaigns, say, against the war in Algeria, against social issues, as well as prison reform. He got involved in the prison reform in France and visited prisons in America as well.

Read More

Architectural Design In Prison

1820 Words | 8 Pages

When it comes to the idea of a prison, it brings up a multitude of images for different people. The relationship between media representations of prisons and public understanding of imprisonment is complex precisely because the prison carries multifarious symbolic meaning, which vary between different media and genres such as in television programs, including documentaries, dramas, and reality TV. Some may visualize prison as storage where maximum criminals are allocated per minimum spaces are in order, while others see a character- and lightless community where repentance is nurtured. Those kinds of perceptions are obsolete, yet both correspond to architectural configurations, which remain to function at this generation. Although, the number

Read More

Disciplinary Civilization Analysis

4020 Words | 17 Pages

In my first reading of Michel Foucault’s book Discipline and Punishment, I looked at the penal system specifically the prison system as the center of the disciplinary society. Given how the prison seems to be the central idea in his work. But through looking at the other works of Foucault and after reassessing Discipline and Punishment I realized it was not that the prison system was at the center of a disciplinary society rather it was simply a part of the disciplinary system as a whole. One key area that Foucault highlights early on in his book though is the transitioning of the penal systems in the late 18th century and in the beginning of the 19th century where he places side by side the torture and public execution of an individual and the daily schedule of young prisoners in Paris which is 80 years after the torture account; a transition from the old system wherein punishment, torture and public execution were all utilized as a means of separating those who cross their boundaries with the higher power which was at this time the

Read More

Gentle Way Of Punishment Analysis

1654 Words | 7 Pages

Bastoy prison prioritizes rehabilitation as the primary strategy to reduce the risk of future murdering, rather than punish the murderers (Ugelvik & Dullum, 2012). This is because they believe that reducing the risk of reoffending is the most important things to do and if it is failed, what is the point of punishment. For Foucault, “the punishment were intended not to efface a crime, but to prevent its repetition.” Hence, Bastoy aims to instill the values of responsibility, trust, accountability and leadership. It is proven to be effective because the recidivism rates for Bastoy prison are just 16% compared to the rate in the U.S. which is 60% (Ugelvik & Dullum, 2012).

Read More

Analysis Of Discipline And Punish By Foucault

1259 Words | 6 Pages

In Discipline and Punish, Foucault asserts that we are living in a disciplinary society. Prison is used as a compelling example. Foucault asks, “Is it surprising that prisons resemble factories, schools, barracks, hospitals, which all resemble prisons?” (p. 228). Bureaucracies combine similar methods as prisons for arranging and disciplining bodies in an effort to exert and retain power in the status quo.

Read More

More about Comparing Foucault's Discipline And Punish

Related Topics

Open Document