ipl-logo

Critical Appraisal Of Qualitative Research

4364 Words18 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: Qualitative research paradigms

Critical Appraisal
Qualitative Research Article M. Sofi Goerdt
University of Mary Introduction
Nursing research has been defined as a systematic inquiry to develop knowledge regarding issues of importance to nurses (Polit & Beck, 2017). Utilizing evidence-based practice, nurses are able to integrate research findings into clinical practice and clinical decisions (Polit & Beck, 2017). There are two paradigms that support nursing research: the positivist paradigm and the constructivist paradigm (Polit & Beck, 2017). The positivist paradigm is associated with quantitative research and utilizes scientific and statistical methods to gather and analyze evidence to affect nursing practice (Polit & Beck). Qualitative research, on the other …show more content…

A good interviewer/researcher is one who is able to gain the trust of the study participants (Polit & Beck, 2017). It is imperative that the researcher/interviewer be a good listener and not offer advice or opinions (Polit & Beck, 2017). In the above study, there is no indication that the interviewers engaged in offering opinionated advice. Indeed, the researchers of the study explain that they adhered to established strategies in qualitative studies that address trustworthiness (Erikson & Davies, 2017). The researchers describe that they engaged in reflexivity, which involves self-reflection regarding one’s bias and preconceptions (Erikson & Davies, 2017; Polit & Beck, 2017). In addition, the researchers explored emerging themes and presented the values to three participants who affirmed the conceptualizations (Erikson & Davies, 2017). The self-awareness of the researchers allowed for trust to be established and for a decreased tendency towards …show more content…

Researchers collect data, categorize and analyze them, discover emerging phenomena and repeat the process (Polit & Beck, 2017). In keeping with the grounded theory methodology, the researchers of the above study confirmed that data analysis commenced with the first interview and continued throughout data collection (Erikson & Davies, 2017). Data accuracy and completeness was assured until data saturation was achieved (Erikson & Davies, 2017). The researchers were thorough in their descriptions of the data analysis process as they explain how the data was coded and categorized. This process is explained in the section below. Through the descriptions offered by the researchers, the reader has an increased understanding of the complexity of analyzing data in a qualitative study. Additionally, the researchers provide a detailed explanation of how grounded theory was applied to data analysis in this study. The researchers of the study do not state if the data analysis was conducted manually or with a computer program. Computer-assisted qualitative data analysis software allows a researcher to enter the data and the software then codes the data, displays texts and examines relationships between the data (Polit & Beck, 2017). Despite this, the researcher must do the coding and analyze the data as the software does not have this capability (Polit

Show More
Related
2427 Words | 10 Pages

Thematic analysis allows for the identification, construction and labeling of recurrent themes and the interpretation of these themes in the context of the research question. For the purposes of this study we will consider relationships between themes and consider developing a conceptual model of the data given our overarching objective to develop an evaluation and implementation tool. Thus, our project will use thematic analysis with tenets of grounded theory. Grounded theory aims to develop a conceptual understanding of a phenomenon with the resulting constructed theory being co-developed by the research team and participants. Interviews will be done virtually

Read More
758 Words | 4 Pages

Qualitative research is intimidating to many because it involves talking to people, learning about the culture and language, revising surveys to fit the community’s definitions and views, and revisiting people. With qualitative data, one cannot punch data immediately after the initial interview; this data takes a lot of time to fully gather. Additionally, qualitative data is seen as softer compared to quantitative. Thus when publishing and presenting research, Cropley explains that it is important to be upfront with one’s bias and to be skeptical of one’s own data.

Read More
2825 Words | 12 Pages

only 10 research articles were included in this study. The 10 articles published from 1996 to 2014 were selected and formed the basis for this review. The earliest study included was published in 1996, with most studies published in 2014. The articles were published in nursing and Medical journals .

Read More
849 Words | 4 Pages

One key factor in the grounded theory that the term grounded means the theory is embedded in data that have been systematically obtained through research. Allan (2003) emphasize that grounded theory is a powerful research method for collecting and analyzing data. Also, the data collected through interviews are more reliable than the data gathered by questions in a survey (Allan, 2003). That is because in a face-to-face situation the researcher can find out whether the interviewee is the appropriate person to answer the questions or not. In addition, having the ability to discuss issues in details is an advantage, as well as obtaining clarifications on certain points, and the ability to initiate the process for data analysis as early as the end of the first interview.

Read More
1585 Words | 7 Pages

My observations are that Business Management and Fine Art degree subjects are not normally focussed on any specific career path. The QAA subject benchmark statements used in Higher Education to design degree courses refer to the knowledge and skills generally associated with students who have studied a particular degree subject (QAA, 2008; 2015; 2017). According to the QAA, (2015) Business and Management benchmark statements, the skills and knowledge students gain from their degree “...while being highly appropriate to a career in business and management, are not restricted to this...” (QAA, 2015:6) The skills include subject specific skills and generic skills relevant to work including: networking skills, numeracy and commercial acumen, problem

Read More
1003 Words | 5 Pages

The analysis of the qualitative assessment results identifies several usability problems that need to be considered in more detail. One of these problems has to do with the cognitive load. According to Zahavi [6] information overload appears when the ability to perceive and understand is exceeded by the amount of informatin presented by a user interface, to the point of facilitating information processing errors. Further work related with this topic should be done, namely to achieve a better organization of the information and an improved version of the graphical design, too flat with poor color contrast. In addition to problems with the cognitive load, the analysis indicates potential problems in the effective presentation of the information.

Read More
581 Words | 3 Pages

The methods that were used throughout the article varied. One method both the authors used was the Data from in-depth interviews. As well as semi structured interview were

Read More
374 Words | 2 Pages

In qualitative research, bias can affect the validity and reliability of the research findings. However, the researcher can recognize the bias and work to reduce it. In this specific research study, interviews are heavily relied upon to receive data. During interviews, personal bias from the interviewer can skew the data. One of the major factors for me as a researcher is that I already have my personal beliefs on the topic, which could affect how I ask questions or what I ask in order to facilitate the responses that I want.

Read More
635 Words | 3 Pages

Next is selecting the proper location(s) and subjects, then collecting the proper data (386). After the data is collected it must be analyzed, from then forward the conceptual/theoretical

Read More
973 Words | 4 Pages

However, critics of qualitative research say it is time consuming, intellectually fatiguing and depends for its success upon the ability of the investigator. But, it is expected of a researcher to act responsibly and professionally to minimise errors especially common in qualitative research. In my case, indeed I had to dedicate valuable time and sobered up to the task of having to understand the different data that came my way. I was as open-minded as possible to avoid biases in the research process. I made sure respondents felt free as much as they could, without creating an artificial outlook or environment that could create a boundary between them and myself, because the artificial environment makes the respondents say what you want to

Read More
1343 Words | 6 Pages

Question 1: The credibility of a research is impacted by the methods in which the findings from semi-structured interview are presented (Low, 2013, p. 98). Although unstructured interviews are an effective method to utilize when gathering data about individuals, it is at a disadvantage when it comes to capturing what those individuals do. On the other hand, semi-structured interviews – such as the one in this research study – have numerous advantages. Firstly, they are cost-effective and can amass a large amount of data in little to no time (Low, 2013, p.88).

Read More
786 Words | 4 Pages

The purpose with this qualitative study is to investigate and characterize the experiences of men and women living with HIV in Sweden and explain these experiences in relation to their social well-being. Furthermore, the study aims to describe common patterns of experiences of people living with HIV infections as well as explore and describe how the infection has affected and changed people’s way of living. Social discrimination, life changes, emotional disturbances as well as dealing with the difficulties will be examined. 1.2 Central Research Question What are the experiences of HIV-positive adults living in Sweden, from the HIV-infected individual’s perspective?

Read More
745 Words | 3 Pages

The research findings of participants’ accounts and how they are examined, understood, and described were shaped in some way by the researcher’s biases and expectations. Steps were taken during this study to help ensure trustworthiness of the researcher’s account. These include member checking, obtaining feedback from external reviewers including a qualitative researcher and providing a rich description of participants accounts. The member checking was done with only two of the six participants due to the availability of participants after the data collection.

Read More
1717 Words | 7 Pages

In order to unmask the some other secreted factors which were not recognized by quantitative analysis, qualitative method of data collection was also used. Qualitative analysis is an efficient tool for obtaining information regarding values, attitude, opinions and behavior of specific population (Mack et al., 2005). Qualitative investigation in current study was mainly based on key informant interviews. The key informants are the informed people whose experiences, views and annotations relevant to the specific topic; are shared by the researchers in order to explore a occurrence under study (Patton, 1990). Different people have different capabilities for explaining and verbally expressing information however, it is useful to take small number

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

Trustworthiness and Credibility Parallel to the criteria of quantitative research as suggested by Guba (1981), such as internal validity, reliability, and objectivity, qualitative research has also different criteria for its evaluation (Lincoln, 1995). We considered the trustworthiness criteria as suggested by Guba and Lincoln (1985) such as credibility, confirmability or auditability, dependability, and transferability or fittingness of the study (Cutcliffe & McKenna, 1999; Lincoln & Guba, 1985; Sandelowski, 1986; Streubert-Speziale, 2007). Trustworthiness. Is present throughout the entire execution of our research. Honesty and determination have been implemented to prove the trustworthiness of this study.

Read More

More about Critical Appraisal Of Qualitative Research

Related Topics

Open Document