ipl-logo

Educ Vs Earls Case Study

507 Words3 Pages

Mod: Today we are speaking with our own Janelle Norkevicus regarding her thoughts on Board of Education of Independent School District #92 of Pottawatomie County v. Earls (2002). Good Morning Janelle, how are you?
Janelle: Good Morning. I am well. Yes, I am here to discuss the Board of Educ vs. Earls.
Mod: So give us a little history on the case.
Janelle: Well, this case started off with the Tecumseh School in Oklahoma requiring all students in the middle and high schools that participate in extracurricular activities to take a urine drug test. Now this school is a public school, and the activities include clubs and sports.
Mod: What was done with the tests?
Janelle: From what I read, the tests that were given were only to detect …show more content…

Both sets of parents filed suit stating this was a violation of the Fourth Amendment.
Mod: Was there a case precedent for or against?
Janelle: The attorneys used Vernonia School District 47 J vs. Acton, which the Supreme Court ruled that suspicion less drug testing of student athletes was constitutional. The Federal District Court upheld the policy, granting the Board’s Motion for Summary Judgment.
Mod: What happened next?
Janelle: The Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals reversed in favor of Earls and James. It was decided in the appeal that the school must show an identifiable drug abuse problem among most of the group of students in order to test. The Tenth Circuit held that the School District failed to meet the requirement that there was an actual drug problem. The case was then argued in March of 2002 in front of the U.S. Supreme Court. It was decided as it was in Vernonia School District 47 J vs. Acton that students that participate in these activities would expect limited privacy, so the drug tests did not violate that. In fact, since the only real consequence was expulsion out of the group, it was determined that it was for the safety of the students to allow the drug testing. So the Supreme Court reversed the Tenth Circuit Court’s decision. It was a close vote, 5 to

Show More
Related

Persuasive Essay: Random Drug Testing In Public Schools

1759 Words | 8 Pages

Randomly testing students for drugs in school would allow them to get help from teachers, counselors, and other adults. Many students stated that they would not be embarrassed if they were to be called down to take a random drug test. Randomly testing will help stop drug abuse in student athletes who wish to continue to participate in sports. “An experimental pilot study of student athletes involved in RSDT programs showed an associated reduction in drug use” (DuPont 841). Random drug testing will also make student athletes stop using drugs “if they’re really serious about playing” (Marciana np).

Read More

Persuasive Essay: Drug Testing In Public Schools

665 Words | 3 Pages

Drug Testing in Public Schools Drug testing in public schools has been a controversial topic for many years. While some people believe it is necessary to ensure the safety of students, others argue that it violates their privacy. In my opinion I would argue for Drug Testing in Schools because it’s a different but a much better way of figuring out who is smoking in school. Students have the right to come to school without having to be involved with drugs. According to “On the demand occupational medicine” “Over 50% of teenagers, both middle school and high school, report that drugs are used, kept or sold at their schools— a scary fact for parents and school administration.

Read More

Drug Testing Persuasive Essay

728 Words | 3 Pages

In recent years, the government has increased their funding in the campaign to encourage drug tests in many schools across the country, to decrease the number of students that already take harmful drugs, however, this system of drug testing has many faults, as it is proven to be ineffective to stop students from using drugs, it is expensive for schools to pay for, and it invades the rights and privacy of many, if not all, high school students. The government has a good reason to be launching these random drug tests, as a survey taken in 2014 shows that drug use has been increasing exponentially in 8th, 10th, and 12th graders. The top drugs that have increased in use are marijuana, alcohol, and inhalants, the numbers have increased almost dramatically, almost a 12% increase of the U.S. student population from the year before, which is a large group of people, considering that there are approximately 319 million people in the United States. With these unstable numbers,

Read More

Drug Testing In Schools Case Study

779 Words | 4 Pages

In Oklahoma, two students (Daniel James and Lindsey Earls) took legal action in stating their opions about the drug testing in schools. The drug testing students was created by the Tecumseh, Oklahoma School District which requires all middle, as well as high school students to participate in urinalysis testing for drugs in order to participate in any extracurricular school activity. This case applies to the Acton’s case because both Acton, Earl, and James all disagreed upon the act of drug testing students. For whatever apparent reason, James Acton’s parents refused to allow James be drug tested. Why?

Read More

Argumentative Essay: Random Drug Testing In Schools

1347 Words | 6 Pages

Drug testing began in schools in the 1980s. Before the 1980s it was rare to be tested for drugs unless you were an athlete or there was a suspicion in school. Over the last thirty years drug use has spread all across high schools throughout the United States and random drug testing has become more popular. Schools have adopted random drug testing to hopefully reduce drug use among students (Frequently Asked Questions About Drug Testing in Schools). Drug tests usually test for marijuana, cocaine, opioids pain relievers oxycontin and vicodin, amphetamines, and PCP.

Read More

Why We Should Take Drug Testing In Schools Essay

795 Words | 4 Pages

Even though the supreme court had rounded out this case in mid 2002, there are still many faults on why it should not be allowed unless they voluntarily do the testing; people have somatic rights, and they should not be forced to drug test for a school, where is the trust if the schools feel they must drug test all of their students, and do schools think just because of drug testing everyone, their students will not try the drugs?

Read More

Should Students Get Drug Tested Essay

518 Words | 3 Pages

“The primary purpose of drug test is not only to punish students who will use illicit drugs but to prevent future illicit drug use to help students already using become drug free”. The use of drugs in America expand every year and is growing at this exact moment .In 2013 around 570,000 Americans twelve and older reported died from drug use. Now that five years have went by and more drugs have been created the population of drugs have went up. Although, people may disagree that kids shouldn’t be tested unless its a school active or extracurricular.

Read More

Persuasive Essay: Random Drug Testing In Our School System

1818 Words | 8 Pages

Introduction draft Hi I am Jaimee Burke and these are my partners Bryn Grant and Maddy Wright. Random drug testing needs to be required in every school system in America. Do you want your kids doing drugs on a school campus and getting caught but you can 't prove it? Of course not if your kids or friend is accused by this big statement of doing drugs you want the facts that they have.

Read More

Drug Testing In Sports Essay

659 Words | 3 Pages

Drug testing at sporting events is the way to ensure that all sportsmen are playing on a equal level and nobody is more advantaged than one another. 2.2) Yes, in todays society parents and coaches want their children/athletes to excel and be the best and they will go to extreme levels to ensure that their child/athletes is the best. They will go as far as giving teens anabolic steroids which can be a serious hazard to the teens health. Drug testing at school level is to ensure that children are not threatening their health as well as to make sure they still remember to have fun with sport.

Read More

Persuasive Essay: Drug Testing In Schools

369 Words | 2 Pages

People may argue that drug testing throughout schools violates a person’s Constitutional rights; however, unless schools start random drug testing their students, drug abuse in teenagers is going to increase tremendously. Drug abuse that occurs within the school puts the faculty, students, and administrators in danger. Parents are putting their child in the school’s hands by sending

Read More

Drug Testing In Schools Essay

835 Words | 4 Pages

Many of the testing organizations say that athletes are a major function in the schools and are “role models” to others. When the students observe that the athletes are striving greatly without drugs in their hands then they will too. If this is uneffective to the students and they choose to be caught by testing then they will still be offered a chance in counseling or even more severe help. There are people all over everybody's community that want to help the ones that do not understand what will appear in their future, if continued. This is not the only way to prevent drug usage because their is many more and they seem to be working.

Read More

Arguments Against Mandatory Drug Testing In Schools

501 Words | 3 Pages

One reason is several studies have found that students subject to mandatory drug testing report less drug use than students in schools without testing (Frequently Asked Questions about Drug Testing in Schools). In addition, since the Supreme Court ruled that drug testing in schools is constitutional in 2002, teen drug use has declined by 23 percent, and with more than 840,000 fewer students reporting using illegal drugs than in 2001 (Should Schools do Random Drug testing, John P. Walters). Conducting drug tests on students who wish to participate in extracurricular activities gives students a clear reason to never use drugs. Another reason Northville High school should conduct drug tests is teachers who work in schools where drug tests are given have noted a decrease in drug use and an improvement in discipline (Creating Safe and Drug-Free Schools: An Action Guide). Conducting drug tests would also allow the School to discover and treat student drug problems before they become serious.

Read More

Drug Testing In Schools Essay

723 Words | 3 Pages

Some believe that the tests are too costly, and the funds could be used more effectively, but it is such a small price to pay to potentially save a child’s life. Others feel that students will cheat and bring in someone else’s urine. However, if you require the urine sample be provided “in house” they would not be able to cheat. Extracurricular activities and athletics are pro-social activities that may be protective of substance use. When a positive drug test leads to suspension from these activities, the effects can be detrimental (John).

Read More

Student Drug Testing Argument Analysis

1734 Words | 7 Pages

With drug testing amongst students increasing in popularity, many high schools have now implemented varying policies about drug and substance use and abuse. Schools adopting drug testing systems initiate policies that contain some sort of drug testing program for students involved in extracurricular activities. Most of these systems include a punishment plan to follow those students whose drug tests come back positive, in attempt to aid in the rehabilitation process. The controversy concerning high school student drug testing continues to increase with educated arguments on both sides of the topic. Specific aspects of drug testing are disagreed upon, such as which students are tested, how often tests are done, and the disciplinary action taken,

Read More

Should Drug Testing Be Mandatory Essay

901 Words | 4 Pages

Mandatory drug testing is a very controversial topic. High schools all over the world test and many have different opinions on the topic. Some believe that this is needed to keep kids drug free. Others, however, believe it is an invasion of privacy and is unconstitutional. The testing is mostly for people who are in extracurriculars.

Read More

More about Educ Vs Earls Case Study

Related Topics

Open Document