Liam Callahan Mr. Lynch English 1 Honors 26 March 2024 Act III Scene I Fault Analysis Essay Although many others are at fault for the events of Act III Scene I in Shakespeare’s Romeo and Juliet, the character that bears the most responsibility for the fight that occurs in this scene is Mercutio. This is because he raises the tension against Tybalt by insulting him, leading to the duel and the death of both himself and later Tybalt, but ultimately the exile of Romeo from Verona. Furthermore, Mercutio had the opportunity to stop the duel between himself and Tybalt after Tybalt had drawn the first blood, but instead, Mercutio continued the fight, throwing his glove in the face of Tybalt, and engaging in further combat until his untimely death. …show more content…
Mercutio is also responsible for the continuation of the duel after Tybalt drew first blood. Although it is not depicted in the text, in the Globe Theater Production of Act III Scene I, Mercutio and Tybalt started off the duel in intense combat, but after a while Tybalt laid a hit on the forearm of Mercutio, leaving a bloody wound as he crouched down in pain. As Mercutio’s weapons laid aside him, Tybalt took a bow of grace in front of Mercutio, symbolizing what he thought was a victorious duel over the royals, as he had drawn first blood and assumed that was the end of the fight, that they were only fighting to first blood, not to the death. If Mercutio had agreed to end the fight there, it is likely his life would be spared. However, Mercutio threw his glove in the face of Tybalt, then stood up with his rapier and sword in his hands, and continued to swing at Tybalt. This action of Mercutio throwing his glove at Tybalt was insulting, and it further provoked the carrying on of the …show more content…
Mercutio’s ignorance and his insults towards Tybalt caused the duel between himself and Tybalt to carry on and his death to follow. It also set the stage for the tragic events that later occurred in Act III Scene I. The responsibility for the events that occurred in Act III Scene I is bestowed mainly upon Mercutio, as his actions played the primary role in initiating the duel between himself and Tybalt and aligned for Tybalt’s death and Romeo’s exile to occur. However, some blame for these occurrences can be additionally placed on other characters, like Tybalt and even Romeo. Tybalt is responsible for the death of Mercutio, a royal and the Prince’s son, and faces the consequences once he returns and is killed in a duel with Romeo. On the other hand, Romeo is responsible for the death of Tybalt, and his prior interactions with Tybalt were the reason that he came to speak with Mercutio and Benvolio, which is where the scene first escalated. Even though Romeo and Tybalt played crucial roles and are partially held responsible for the events of Act III Scene I, Mercutio’s actions provoked and insulted Tybalt, and directly led to his