ipl-logo

Philomena Ethical Dilemma Essay

2195 Words9 Pages

Introduction
Philomena is a piece of literature which views the oppression of unmarried mothers in Ireland during the 1950’s. This essay will give light to a specific ethical dilemma that has been chosen within the literature. Firstly, an examination of the literature will be conducted and an ethical dilemma will be considered. Secondly, the procedure of resolving the ethical dilemma will be discussed. Furthermore, discussion will occur on the importance’s of a code of ethics amongst social care workers and the values and principles contained.
Part A
Ireland in the 1950’s was profoundly influenced by the role of the Catholic Church and Catholic nuns made up the majority of female workers (Tentler, 2007). In the case where a young woman would have premarital sex or fall pregnant at a young age it was seen as shameful to society and these women were incarcerated in an Abbey. The consequence for having premarital sex was exorbitant. It is evident in the literature that Philomena fell pregnant as a teenager and was sent by her family to the Roscrea Abbey for being labelled …show more content…

They believed that her pain throughout labour was penitence for her sins and therefore administered no pain relief despite Philomena needing/asking for it (Philomena, 2013). Philomena worked within the Abbey for four years as compensation for the nuns taking her in. Her son was in a separate location in the Roscrea Abbey and Philomena could only visit him for an hour a day once all her main chores were completed (Philomena, 2013). This process occurred until the day, a couple from America came to Roscrea and paid the nuns to “adopt” a child. The Catholic Church had the power and the nuns used this power to repress the vulnerable young mothers. Philomena’s story leads from there in hopes to find her son who was taken from her (Philomena,

Show More
Related
896 Words | 4 Pages

Awful Disclosures was fuel for a pre-existing, anti-Catholic fire. Anti-Catholics now had an extremely popular first-hand account that would work towards the discreditation of Catholicism. The book’s contents were gruesome and heavily detailed, which did not make the distinction between truth and lie easy to identify. Monk claimed that the convent would force the nuns to be intimate with priests, then baptize and kill any babies born from these relations. It was also written that the monastery had a number of terrible additions, such as prisons for nuns who acted out, underground tunnels, secret entrances, and the like.

Read More
635 Words | 3 Pages

Sal’s mother was devastated that the baby died and thought it was her fault so she felt useless. Both Sal and Phoebe’s mothers felt useless and unwanted before they

Read More
1718 Words | 7 Pages

British Association of Counselling and Psychotherapy (BACP) are the main and the biggest expert relationship for guiding and psychotherapy in the United Kingdom with more than 34,000 individual members. The Association was established in 1971 and works deliberate self-administrative plans for individual counsellors/psychotherapists, bosses, instructional classes and administrations. The BACP Ethical Framework came into power in April 2002 and gives an expert framework to guides, delineating key zones of obligation and principles of behaviour (Rugby 2010). At present BACP authorises post graduate courses at 30 UK Universities over every one of the four home nations. More than 24,000 members have embraced centre preparing in advising and psychotherapy.

Read More
1610 Words | 7 Pages

I, the worst of all, depicts the story of Sor Juana Ines De La Cruz, who was a nun who advocated for equal rights in the 17th century, and died of the plague in 1695 in the New World. This paper draws on secondary sources from Paz, Lavrin, and Ramirez to argue that Sor Juana’s death is ultimately the consequence of systemic sexism within the Church and society. The Church allowed, in the 17th century, women refuge and a livelihood in an era where they had few other opportunities outside of marriage. However, women took part in an institution fully dominated by men who believed that women were biologically and intellectually inferior. These men used women within the convent to control their will.

Read More
473 Words | 2 Pages

This article on ethics was really interesting and a dilemma that is prevalent within criminal justice. In the article Dr. Steven Davis recognized that students cheating in high school increased by 20% in the 1940 to 75% today. Davis stated, "If students lack ethics in high school and college, then there should be little surprise that they lack ethics in their careers. (2008). " This observation by Davis holds some value, because individuals that is willing to cheat to get ahead, definitely has no problem crossing ethical lines, because in their mind the wrong is acceptable, just as it was when they cheated.

Read More
557 Words | 3 Pages

Immodest Acts: The Life of a Lesbian Nun in Renaissance Italy by Judith C. Brown is an intriguing and profusely detailed tale of Sister Benedetta Calini, also known as the Abbess of the Convent of the Mother of God, who reflects the escalation and the collapse of an authoritative woman in a religious society, and gives an initial record of lesbianism in European history. In this critique of Judith C. Brown’s, Immodest Acts: The Life of a Lesbian Nun in Renaissance Italy, I will analyze her reason for writing the novel, her use of data, and her diction. Judith’s reason for writing this tale was to present how some women that were placed in the convent during the seventeenth century had authority, and let it get the best of them. She also presented

Read More
580 Words | 3 Pages

Practitioners must follow and comply with the ethical codes because it sets the minimum standards for their professional organization. Ethical codes are based on values, principles and moral decisions that are to be made regarding professional behavior. These codes are not a guarantee that they will be followed nor do they provide all the answers, however, they are highly expected to be followed in order to best guide them through common situations and issues. Two codes of ethics that are commonly used between mental health professionals are the American Mental Health Counselors’ Association (AMHCA) and the International Association of Marriage and Family Counselors (IAMFC). In the paragraphs to follow, it will show what the IAMFC codes represent, the differences and similarities between the two codes, and insights into how the codes are applicable during work as a counselor.

Read More
719 Words | 3 Pages

The general definition of ethics refers to moral principles or values that generally govern the conduct of an individual or group. The American Psychological Association's (APA) Ethical Principles of Psychologists (aspirational guidelines) and Code of Conduct (enforceable rules) are the obligatory rules and principles that must be followed to ensure the safety of humans and preserve the integrity within the field of Psychology. As psychologist we are morally obligated to respect the rights and dignity of every research participants no matter their age, gender, gender identity, race, ethnicity, culture, national origin, religion, sexual orientation, disability, language, or socioeconomic status (APA). The principal and codes outline the obligations

Read More
937 Words | 4 Pages

Ethical issues are important rules that people and organizations set for others to follow. Ethical issues inform individuals of things that are okay and not okay to do in a professional setting. Consequences for not following ethical issues include, temporary leave, termination, lawsuit, etc. The textbook Issues and Ethics in the Helping Profession lists a variety of ethical issues that professionals must follow.

Read More
1078 Words | 5 Pages

Nursing implications The registered nurse plays a crucial role in the ethical dilemma of LT for alcoholic cirrhosis patients. To begin, the nurse will complete a thorough assessment and past medical history of the patient. In order to identify patients at risk with or of an alcohol use disorder, it is recommended to use the AUDIT questionnaire. This questionnaire is known for Alcohol Use Disorder Identification Test.

Read More
1789 Words | 8 Pages

From time to time, social work practitioners face different challenges and one of such example is being confronted with ethical dilemmas. An ethical dilemma is defined as “when the social worker sees himself or herself as facing a choice between two equally unwelcoming alternatives, which may involve a conflict of moral values, and it is not clear which choice will be the right one” (Banks, 2012). Ethical dilemmas can occur in the context of either client or organisational-related conflict situations at work. The first ethical dilemma is when the patient refuses medical treatment and services because he or she would not accept that there is any problem.

Read More
1762 Words | 8 Pages

Organizational Analysis An organizational analysis is a critical component in identifying problems or insufficiencies a business or organization may have. The organization’s culture, mission, values, and beliefs are evaluated. By performing an organizational analysis, one may be able to strategically develop a plan to correct issues. This paper will discuss healthcare systems as complex adaptive systems (CAS), evaluate Baptist Health System (BHS) as an organization, and explore BHS’s readiness for change.

Read More
368 Words | 2 Pages

Kerridge et.al (2009), developed an ethical decision making model made up of seven steps to guide a social worker to identify both ethical issues and to evaluate the values of the identified issues (Kerridge et.al, 2009). This model is applied to the three options that are elaborated and illustrated in Appendix’s B. C. and D. The first step in the model is to ‘clearly state the problem’ which is the argument of self-determination and own wishes versus Sophie’s mother’s wishes and the law. This elicits questions such as ‘Is a sixteen year old girl mature enough to make the decision of termination?’

Read More
776 Words | 4 Pages

It has become apparent throughout time that moral conflicts are constantly challenging engineers. Whether it is related to infamous incidents that led to the downfall of professionals or the daily obstacles that engineers face, moral excellence is of the utmost importance in any field. Intellectual and character virtues, as exemplified in the philosophical context, are essential to engineering ethics. Of these virtues, engineers should strive for honesty, courage and fairness. Achieving the aforementioned moral excellences will allow engineers to conduct good judgments and commitment to their professional life.

Read More
1045 Words | 5 Pages

Merriam-Webster dictionary defines ethics as, “the discipline dealing with what is good and bad and with moral duty and obligation.” Righteousness and virtuous are a few words I would use to define the term ethics. But where do our ethics truly arise from? From birth, we begin to learn things from our homes and community that shapes the way we view things. The cycle of socialization as describe by Bobbie Harro in Readings for Diversity and Social Justice plays a huge role in determining what values and ethics we carry on throughout our lifetime.

Read More

More about Philomena Ethical Dilemma Essay

Related Topics

Open Document