ipl-logo

Should College Athletes Be Paid Analysis

1057 Words5 Pages

Throughout researching the topic of college athletes being paid, I came across authors like Laura Pappano, Joe Posnanski, and Michael Rosenberg. Laura Pappano and Jose Posnanski’s argument discusses that college athletes should not be paid while Michael Rosenberg expresses the idea that the stars of these college sports should.College athletes may attend college on a scholarship, but I disagree with the arguments presented by Pappano and Posnanski. I agree with Rosenberg and believe that college athletes should be paid. In “How Big-Time Sports Ate College Life,” Laura Pappano expresses the idea that college sports ruined college entirely with its “misguided fears.” As I further engaged with the article I found myself in agreement when she …show more content…

A quote from the article presented that I can relatively say I disagree with is when Posnanski states, “Big-time athletes do get paid. They get free college tuition.” Although ‘big-time’ athletes get a free college tuition, they have absolutely no time to go out and get a job, and work for the money they will need once out of college. College athletes spend their time being in college and when they aren’t doing that they’re going to practice and games to fulfill the ‘athlete’ section of that title. These college athletes only have their free tuition because of their abilities to play sports well. Once out of college these athletes will not have the money to support themselves since they lacked the time while at practice. Who are we kidding? As presented, “the chances of going from college to pro were less than 2 percent. The NCAA found that 11.6 percent of college baseball players play in the Major Leagues, though 0.6 percent of high school players ultimately get that far.” As I was discussing earlier, these student athletes are left with no money because the likelihood is that they will not go pro and make $5.15 million a year, instead they will spend their first few years after college working to try and make money to support themselves because they were not economically prepared. There is no free tuition for life. I believe that college athletes practice and play as if it is their job to do so, shouldn’t they be paid for

Show More
Related
471 Words | 2 Pages

Sports writer Joe Posnanski’s article “College Athletes Should Not Be Paid” argument over Dallas Morning News Editorial’s article, “paying them is fair, but it doesn't address college athletes' real need: an education” is more convincing to believe that college athletes should not be paid while receiving the benefits of a free education. DMN states that college athletes should be paid, because NCAA generate millions of income because of these players through private contracts. However, Posnanski’s claim that big time players already are paid through free college tuition, as well as covered room and board (Posnanski, 585). Even though DMN claims that college athletes go through difficult education process and may not be able to have chance to play professionally, he then correlated his source of information to the website of the NCAA, however, there is concern if this institution inflated the facts on the website (DMN). In contrast, Posnanski says argument of “College players are the reason why these schools generating so much money and they deserve a much bigger piece of the pie” is not really right.

Read More
487 Words | 2 Pages

Most of the money they need has to come from parents because unlike pro athletes who have extra time to work, the collegiate athletes are working on schooling during

Read More
1283 Words | 6 Pages

Dalton Collins Berthot English III 2/24/2017 College Athletes Should Not Be Paid College athletes are given scholarships to cover their tuition and other expenses in college, so should they be paid a salary for their athletic performances as well? They are receiving something far more valuable than a chance to play college ball. They are receiving an education that will provide for them and last a lifetime. College athletes should not be paid to perform on the field or the court. Whether college athletes should be paid or not is a topic that is debated more and more these days.

Read More
2239 Words | 9 Pages

The reasons college athletes should be paid is because although they have their scholarship; it typically does not pay for everything. Secondly other people make money off of the college athletes. And lastly college athletes do not have the time to get a decent job, or even a job at all. The NCAA does not allow athletes to be paid which

Read More
1918 Words | 8 Pages

The reasoning behind the researcher's opinion will be broken down and examined to strengthen the stance even more. College Athletes Should Not Be Paid College athletes across the nation have been calling for a payday, but why? College athletes are not professional athletes, therefore they should not be

Read More
970 Words | 4 Pages

This is one of the many reason why college athletes should receive a stipend from the school they play for. For years, college athletes have gone unpaid

Read More
882 Words | 4 Pages

Each year, many talented young men and women attend colleges across the nation to continue their careers as student-athletes. Because of the time consuming hard work and dedication these individuals put forth year round, many people believe they should receive an annual salary for the entertainment they provide for fans around the world. However, the primary purpose of attending college is to earn an education that will allow one to pursue his or her goal of having a career. Therefore, college athletes should not be paid.

Read More
564 Words | 3 Pages

Jared Welch and Blake Marshall said ‘’The athletes also bring in a lot of money and proponents tend to view the money as an excess, something that isn’t already planned’’. college players should get paid to support their self. People think college athletes should be paid because they are entertainers they bring people out to watch them play football basketball and other sports and that brings money to the schools coaches,athletic directors administrators. ESPN and colleges sports tv channels earn millions off of college athletes that could have a good chance to make it pros or hall of fame and breaked records in the future.

Read More
1439 Words | 6 Pages

Thesis Statement: Although paying college athletes seems unfair, it is the right thing to do because it will convince athletes to get a four year degree, they are the ones who bring money to their school, and it will teach them valuable lessons on how to manage money.  Birkenes, Adele, and Akash Bagaria. "Pay to play: Should College Athletes Be Paid?"  Current Events, a Weekly Reader publication, 6 Feb. 2012, p. 7.  Opposing Viewpoints in Context, link.galegroup.com/apps/doc/A279613787/OVIC?u=avlr&xid=ddc324df.

Read More
1398 Words | 6 Pages

“I’ve been writing about this issue for several years now calling for college athletes to be paid the wages that they deserve and am sad to acknowledge that very little has changed since I was a college athlete at UCLA, so poor that I and most of my teammates could barely scrape by” the author makes it evident that the intended audience is the NCAA to voice his opinion. “ Our efforts earned millions of dollars for the university, both in cash and in recruiting advertisement to attract new students. But I was generally too poor to do anything but study, practice and play.” Biased is viewed throughout the article making it unreliable. “We do have hungry nights that we don’t have enough money to get food in. ...

Read More
1233 Words | 5 Pages

People have debated the century long question about if college athletes should be paid, and in recent years the question has become more and more prominent. The short answer is no, and the evidence that supports that argument is plentiful. Although there are many people who do support the counterargument that college athletes should be paid due to their such tight schedules. There is an argument for both sides of the issue regarding college athletics compensation, but only one side stands higher than the other. That side supports that college athletes should not be getting paid while they attend college just because they play their sport on the side.

Read More
1344 Words | 6 Pages

In conclusion, after reading through two different articles, one opposing the idea that college athletes should be paid and one supporting it, it is safe to say I support it. Even though in the con article a couple good points were made like the problem with Title IX and how female athletes would never be paid as much, there is way more persuading factors and just hard facts for why a college athlete should be paid. I am a college athlete, I have thought to myself every single day “Is this really worth it?”. “I am getting absolutely nothing, I am not turning pro, is

Read More
567 Words | 3 Pages

There is a big question going around the “sports world” right now. Should college athletes be paid? Lots of people have their own opinions about this topic, whether it be that student athletes should be paid or not. You can definitely argue both ways but college athletes should not receive a salary for playing a sport. Let’s look at the evidence that shows that student athlete salaries are an outrageous claim.

Read More
1273 Words | 6 Pages

Taking a look at the average college student, should they be paid for what they are studying? Probably not. Then why should college athletes be paid? They shouldn 't get paid just because of their athletic ability. They shouldn 't be paid because they are students, not professionals.

Read More
1538 Words | 7 Pages

College athletes put in a lot of time, effort, and work into the sport they’ve played since they were young, but they aren’t getting paid for it. These student athletes deserve to be paid because they put in countless hours of hard work and balance sports with school work. The first reason athletes in college do deserve to be compensated is because they don 't have time to fit in work with a school and athletic schedule. College athletes don’t have time to get a real job. Student athletes have a very busy schedule, they don’t have time to fit in a job.

Read More

More about Should College Athletes Be Paid Analysis

Related Topics

Open Document