Hae minlee was killed at the Best Buy parking lot. She was choked to death by the murderers bare hands. There are three possible suspects Jay was a drug dealer. drug dealers by nature are shady people. Jay admits to lying to the police and lying in court but justifies this by saying he was trying to protect his grandmother. Jay said that he was forced to participate because he said Adnan was going to expose his drug dealing. Adnan I was seen at the library when the murder happened and tells everyone that he did not do it because he still liked her and is not that type of person to do stuff like that. Adnan did use drugs with jay at the time but he says that he did not kill Hae and he was seen at the library so that puts him away from the murder