ipl-logo

The Pros And Cons Of US Citizenship Testing In High Schools

559 Words3 Pages
bulb-icon

Recommended: What impact does parental involvement have on education

The US citizenship test is required in Arizona to pass high school. It is required because they want students to have a good understanding of the American government. Some people agree with this and some disagree with this, but most people don’t really care. The people who agree with this want it to be required in more states. The people who disagree with this say the test does not have a lot of information on the American government, and there are many alternatives to the citizenship test.

The citizenship test does not have a lot of information on the American government, and should only be used for its intended purpose. Most of the alternatives require more information to pass. Even if it were to be split into parts, the alternatives would still be more effective than the citizenship test. They are more effective because the test is only meant to cover the basics of the American government instead of information that is difficult to obtain outside of the US. The citizenship test does not have enough information to be taught over 4 years of high school. Most alternatives have information that can be taught for a few weeks each semester for 4 years. …show more content…

The parents of students are trying to change it, the students themselves, and other people not even involved with the schools. There are many people involved with the schools because every parent in Arizona is involved. One argument is that not even 12 states require a test about the American government, and none of them are the citizenship test. Arizona is the only state that requires the citizenship test to pass high school. Currently there are no laws in place and no one in control wants to change this. Most of the state wants this to be changed, but the people in control disagree with

Show More
Related
800 Words | 4 Pages

Have you ever wondered where our laws In Mississippi come from? It might seem like a law fairy is making them pop up, but unfortunately, that is not exactly what happens. It seems that way to us because state laws are something citizens do not have a large role in. However, someone who does have a large role in deciding these state laws is the State Legislature. With that being the case, there is a whole lawmaking process and inside that process are many important people and steps.

Read More
725 Words | 3 Pages

While it is the same today, we also have a much higher population than we used to back when we were settling into our ways as a state. This being said, it is a prime time to bring up another positive of a rewrite, the part-time legislature that we have only gets to meet once every two years and honestly that is not enough time to write a proper budget for our country-sized state. We are a large and strongly urbanized. We need a full time government to run our state and be able to speak up for all of our very loud opinions here in the lone star state, and we cannot do that when our state legislature is only getting 140 day biennial sessions. Now with every positive, a negative will ensue.

Read More
1020 Words | 5 Pages

As a full amendment in our constitution, it should not be changed simply because it’s causing our country inconvenience in some people’s opinion. It will also cause more struggle and poverty for immigrants, legal or illegal, in America, which is something American’s have been working very hard to prevent in recent years. (Ronald Rotunda "Birthright Citizenship Benefits the

Read More
1506 Words | 7 Pages

The state continues to pass legislation that contradicts itself. Hundreds of amendments, laws and regulations make it difficult to carefully draft

Read More
804 Words | 4 Pages

The citizenship requirement under Article 2 of our Constitution has been called stupid, un-American, and cruel. Why is that? Not just our country, but the world has so greatly evolved since colonial times. With such great advances in technology and communication, there are now aspects of our Constitution that no longer make sense or seem old-fashioned. The citizenship requirement should be repealed for a number of reasons, the most important including: (a) it is discriminatory, (b) it is outdated, (c) it does not truly determine loyalty and (d) it is undemocratic.

Read More
1376 Words | 6 Pages

In addition, it violates citizen’s rights and dignity in a manner that runs contrary to the founding principles of this nation. The Immigration law was put in place to lower the rate of illegal immigration but is ineffective and poorly designed, and will lead to long term conflict. It has had numerous negative side effects, hurting Arizona’s businesses, tourism, agriculture, education and population reduction over time causing the unemployment rate to rise tremendously. Arizona’s law is not and should not be the end of the discussion over how to resolve the issues plaguing our nation’s immigration system. Rather than imposing fifty different state immigration laws, U.S. Congress should collaborate to approve a national immigration reform policy that benefits our economy that is more realistic, and serves our nation’s long term

Read More
895 Words | 4 Pages

Looking back in history, amendments with this topic have not been received well, by congress or states. Some states have supported the idea of imposing these limitation but not enough states have felt the need to make them a reality. Ultimately, when there is not enough support from one of these areas there is no way to entertain this idea. Due to the feeling of the lack of necessity this proposed amendment would not generate enough commotion to make it through congress or state

Read More
711 Words | 3 Pages

It is up to the legislature to decide the fate of this through the two-thirds vote. Seeing as this is the number one way that the amendments are usually passed and it's in the U.S.’s best interest to get the whole of the United States under the enforcement of the amendment. The test will most likely be on basic political knowledge and will have to be renewed every two elections. There will be a one week before the election cut off date to complete the test.

Read More
662 Words | 3 Pages

To oppose the pro-standerdized tests, stricter testing decreases student achievement. They feel like the test are "life or death," Therefore memorizing facts opposed to actually learning them. That gives the impression that sudents arent actually learning anything. In conclusion, Removing the tests completly or at least making them smaller would impact future generations wholesale.

Read More
680 Words | 3 Pages

The tests narrow down the curriculum to focus on the subjects that are on the test, forgetting about the other subjects. Standardized tests cannot measure all that schools teach like how to be a problem solver. Standardized tests have not improved America’s education system. Every once in a while the world will submit their schools performance and they will be ranked with

Read More
1130 Words | 5 Pages

Even though many students absolutely hate them, state assessments are a big part of the American education system. Everyone has taken a standardized test at some point in their life, and almost everyone has done poorly on one. They are primarily used as a measurement of how well students learn, but are they truly accurate? There are strong arguments on both sides, which has started a heated conflict about the productiveness of these tests. Standardized testing has been around for many years, starting in Imperial China where it was intended to determine a person’s aptitude for a government position (“Do Standardized Tests Show an Accurate View of Students’ Abilities?”).

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

Just because an 8th grader might be said to be proficient at Mathematics in his state, it doesn’t mean that he/she will also be able to prove it in a test from a different state. Each and every state has a different standard, and as such, will demand so much from their students. The act’s highly flexible provisions have allowed states to make their tests “ordinary”, while others are actually trying to raise the bar for their alumni. To further affect these already inaccurate scores, non-English speakers are subjected to take the same exact tests as their peers. The proponents of No Child Left Behind thought that this would lead to the ESL program to improve itself in order to make the students learn English at a faster rate.

Read More
1304 Words | 6 Pages

When it comes down to the real problem of who needs to find a standardized solution, we need to look at Congress. It is time we hold them accountable and make them see the truth about this test. Congress needs to be pushed and see the effect this one test has on a child. They need to be shown that we can give students a good education even without this terrible and long test they make children take. This issue has been brought to the eyes of our government countless times and needs to be seriously looked at.

Read More
816 Words | 4 Pages

Unlike other states who have an

Read More
820 Words | 4 Pages

“Between pre-K and 12th grade, students took about 112 mandatory standardized exams. The study analyzed the time spent actually taking the tests, but it did not include the hours devoted to preparation ahead of the testing required by the federal government, states or local districts. It also did not include regular day-to-day classroom quizzes and tests in reading, math, science, foreign languages and more.” (Study Reveals How Many 1). This illustrates that students are being taught to learn what is on the test, not what they actually need to

Read More

More about The Pros And Cons Of US Citizenship Testing In High Schools

Related Topics

Open Document